Summarized from anonymous rental reviews on openigloo.
Recent reviews for 1733 1 Avenue highlight a great location with clean, pest-free apartments and a helpful doorman and super. Tenants value easy access to amenities, spacious units, and decent garbage management. However, heating is often problematic, with old radiators causing discomfort in winter. Noise levels are a frequent complaint due to thin walls and street traffic, impacting sleep quality. Management receives mixed feedback—while some find them responsive, several tenants report unresponsiveness and delays in repairs or security deposit returns. Overall, the building suits those prioritizing location and building condition, but heating and management responsiveness remain areas needing improvement.
Reviews (8)
3.5 stars
6 months ago
Pretty Solid, But Thin Walls
Former Tenant
Pros:
Cheap, great location, great building management
Cons:
Window units are so/so, and heat is really hard to control. Either way too hot or way too cold.
3.88 stars
8 months ago
Decent apartment, but pray for no maintenance issues
Former Tenant
Pros:
Fair price, no crazy rent increases, large apartments, night doorman is very kind and caring
Cons:
freezing in the winter due to ancient radiators they refuse to replace, major plumbing problems constantly happen, smoke alarm batteries in the hallway not replaced (beeping all night,) very difficult to get things fixed due to the super and management. My boyfriend had a much better time getting the super to listen to him, but I would not rent here if you are a woman.
Advice to owner:
Treat women with the same respect you do men. Do not talk over us or assume we are making issues up.