Summarized from anonymous rental reviews on openigloo.
Recent reviews for 186 North 12 Street praise its prime location by McCarren Park, spacious units, and luxury amenities like a pool and indoor garage. Tenants find the building well-staffed with friendly doormen and enjoy quietness despite the busy neighborhood. However, the management receives consistent criticism for poor responsiveness, lack of communication, and aggressive fee policies. Many report dated interiors, thin walls causing noise issues, and ongoing maintenance problems such as unreliable HVAC, elevators, and cleanliness lapses. Renters also highlight pest control is generally good, but express frustration over perceived neglect of tenant concerns and calls for building renovation and more tenant-focused management.
Reviews (20)
4.75 stars
2 months ago
I loved living here
Former Tenant
Pros:
The location is amazing, the units are great and in a bit older of a luxury building so they are more spacious and better developed
Cons:
The management is not super responsive to the tenants needs. I had no issues with them so I had no issues living in the building for many years but I know others did.