Summarized from anonymous rental reviews on Openigloo.
Recent tenant reviews for buildings managed by 416 W 23RD STREET PARTNERS 1, LLC reveal persistent management issues. While the location and renovated interiors are appreciated, renters frequently report unaddressed pest infestations (mice and roaches), unreliable elevator service, and broken building facilities like mailboxes and intercoms. Garbage and package management also appear problematic, with trash backups and theft concerns. Tenants describe poor responsiveness from management, leading to unresolved maintenance and tenant conflicts. Despite some praise for individual staff members like the super, overall management is viewed as unresponsive and ineffective, making living conditions challenging despite the desirable location.
Reviews
Former tenant·9 hours ago
Be prepared to do it yourself!
Pros
Location, Location, Location
Cons
The building management is completely unreliable to manage:
maintenance issues
tenant to tenant issues
mail / package theft issues
constant elevator break downs
Mail boxes falling off the wall
Roaches are a constant issue
Mice? I suggest you get a cat
Constant turnover of apartments
Advice to the owners
Get rid of the mice and roaches
Former tenant·2 months ago
Roaches & Refurbs
Pros
Location in West Chelsea, affordability compared to neighboring units, quiet, refurbished interiors, exposed brick, elevator, trash chute
Cons
Roaches, mice, no window in living room, garbage sitting in stairwell, mailbox broken and never fixed in over years, broken appliances, toilet running
