Pros:
The amenities (gym, lounge, rooftop deck) are all lovely and super convenient to have on hand. I had a generally pleasant experience with the other tenants in the building in the elevators or in the halls. The building employees were all very kind and always say hello, strike up a brief conversation in the elevator, or ask if everything in the apartment is working alright. Also, the location is super convenient; There’s a Whole Foods, Target, Trader Joe’s, Marshall’s, TJ Maxx, Dunkin’, Starbucks, and so many other stores and restaurants littered around on 125th Street. On top of that, there’s a lot of train options along 125th Street; The 1/2/3 (2min walk!!), 4/5/6, and the A/B/C/D. All great commute options.
Cons:
Get ready to be creative with your storage. The closets in each bedroom are TINY. And there aren’t any additional storage closets, at least not in my apartment. I personally have a shower curtain rod between two walls to hang most of my shirts, 3 different locations of drawers in my room, and the closet to store clothing. I do have a lot of clothes, but I would be really impressed if someone was able to fit all of their wardrobe in the small bedroom closet. On top of that, I have a queen sized bed and it probably takes up about 85% of the room. Coming from a studio where I used furniture as a makeshift partition to separate my living area from my sleeping area, I had too much furniture for this apartment when I moved in. I had to rehome some items or, if small enough, break them down and store them somewhere within my limited space.
The laundry room has a bunch of machines, which is great for the amount of people in the building. But, I have had a load stolen and moved while doing my laundry here, and it’s hard to get it back if you don’t have sufficient evidence.
Also, I’ve had mail & packages go missing. Whether it’s open when I see it or it never appears, there’s definitely packages that I suspect have gotten stolen.
The closer you live to the roof, the more noisy it can get when people have parties up there. It’s not awful, but just pray nobody starts yelling over loud music. You can hear it loud and clear. Even some tenants around my unit have parties and seem to have no awareness that there’s other people on the same floor. Couples, families, elderly… I can understand wanting to have friends over, but if you want to scream at the top of your lungs, go to a club. Or go on the street and make it everyone’s problem.
Advice to owner:
Redo the closets! Make them cover more wall space and change the facing of the door so it’s a sliding door. Take up more space on storage and less space on the door swinging out.