Summarized from anonymous rental reviews on openigloo.
Tenant feedback for 75 West Street, Manhattan highlights an overall well-maintained building with responsive maintenance and friendly, helpful doormen and superintendents. Apartments feature spacious layouts with flexible walls, good water pressure, and adequate heating. The location is lauded for proximity to multiple subway lines, Whole Foods, and waterfront access, making it convenient for residents. Common amenities include a gym and rooftop with expansive views, though some tenants desire improvements such as updated gym equipment, better rooftop furniture, enhanced lobby aesthetics, and improved window insulation for noise and temperature control. Some criticisms focus on occasional management unresponsiveness and an unfriendly leasing office, though management generally resolves issues promptly. Pest control is effective, and neighbors are mostly pleasant. Despite a few downsides, renters find this a desirable building in FiDi for comfort and convenience.
Reviews (20)
4.62 stars
3 months ago
I thought it was too good to be true, it’s not!
Former Tenant
Pros:
- AMAZING SUPER! Roberto is the best! - super fast maintenance help and I feel like all my issues have been taken seriously and dealt with QUICKLY! - ability to flex and my unit still has a window in each room and apartment still feels spacious! - rent increase was fair (I believe mine was around 5%) - laundry machines just all got replaced this year (2025) which is awesome - gym and the roof are great amenities! - proximity to trains (4,5, R,W, and 1) and West side highway rocks - proximity to whole foods
Cons:
- there is one specific doorman who can be a bit rude from time to time, but the rest of them are so sweet! - I’m in an interior facing unit so natural light isn’t the best, but my apartment is super quiet, so just a bit of a trade off there… - I had one singular roach, one time, in my apartment (I have been living here for almost two years) BUT it was addressed incredibly quickly and exterminator said it was likely one that came through the drains after seeing photos of the bug…. I haven’t seen another one again (my other neighbors I know haven’t seen anything at all and some have lived here for 7+ years) so if anything it shows how seriously they take pest control!
And honestly those are my biggest issues…. I am so lucky to live in this building!!!