410 St Nicholas Avenue,
Manhattan, NY 10027

269 Units

Built in 1926

29 Floors

Rent Stabilized Units: Unknown
Good Cause Evictions: Yes
Evictions: 6
Litigation History: Yes
1 Year Bedbug History: Yes
Pet Friendly: Yes
Available Listings In 410 St Nicholas Avenue
no-listing
Don't miss out on any new listings!
Save buildings to your favorites and we'll let you know as soon as something becomes available.
Hey smart renter!
In the past three years, this building had:
943 complaints
See all complaints about this building in a rental report
Open Violations
A violation is issued to a building when a city inspector from NYC's Department of Housing Preservation and Development validates and confirms a complaint made to 311. The violations listed below are open violations that have yet to be addressed or have not been confirmed as resolved by the city.
Duration in the past 10 years.
Data last updated 13 hours ago.
BUILDING AVERAGE:
0.25 violation per unit
NEW YORK CITY AVERAGE:
0.81 violation per unit
flag
Non-hazardous
12
class A
i.e. no peephole on a door, or no street # on the building, unlawful keeping of animals
MOST RECENT:
May 12, 2024: § 27-2005 adm code repair the broken or defective plastered surfaces and paint in a uniform color all walls and ceiling in the bathroom located at apt 4j, 4th story, 2nd apartment from north at east , section at west
Show all
flag
Hazardous
36
class B
i.e. smoke detector issues, inadequate lighting, no lighting for stairways
MOST RECENT:
May 12, 2024: § 27-2017.3 hmc: trace and repair the source and abate the visible mold condition... appox. 15 sqft at ceiling in the bathroom located at apt 4j, 4th story, 2nd apartment from north at east , section at west
Show all
flag
Immediately hazardous
20
class C
i.e. rodents, pest, mold, inadequate heat or hot water, defective building parts
MOST RECENT:
May 12, 2024: § 27-2031 adm code provide hot water at all hot water fixtures in the entire apartment located at apt 4j, 4th story, 2nd apartment from north at east , section at west
Show all
flag
Missing information/filings
0
class I
Missing or non-compliant with administrative information orders or filings
MOST RECENT:
No violation found...
Show all
Property Owners and Associates
S
410 St Nicholas Property LLC
2.7(30)
Corporate Owner
4 Properties311 Units
Litigation History: Yes
Evictions: 6
E
Elizabeth Rivera
2.7(30)
Agent
Head Officer
4 Properties311 Units
Litigation History: Yes
Evictions: 6
Frequently Asked Questions

Renter Q&A

ask-question
Be the first to ask a question!

Building Ratings

Water Pressure
Cleanliness
Pest Control
Heat
Noise Levels
Owner Responsiveness
Neighbors
Garbage Management

Renter Recommendations

--% of renters recommend this building

--% of renters approve of this owner

Rents and Deposits

-- of renters received their security deposits back
It HAS NOT been reported if this building accepts electronic rent payments.

Reviews (28)

7 months ago
Cheap but Terrible Management
Former Tenant
Pros:
The price is great for the amount of space you get.
Cons:
- Terrible Pest Management: Bed Bugs in the building, Mice in the building - Elevators always breaking - Packages get stolen
7 months ago
shitty management + slumlords
Former Tenant
Pros:
The people in this building are overwhelmingly nice! units are pretty big as well.
Cons:
The management sucks and is unresponsive in a crisis. The stairwells are filthy. The washers and dryers in the laundry room break often. One of the elevators has been out of commission for 3 years, the other two break occasionally. I know multiple units with pest problems.
Advice to owner:
Stop raising the rent if you aren’t going to adjust the quality of the units and fix pipes/heat/infrastructure!
10 months ago
Can't beat the price..
Former Tenant
Pros:
Size of unit and price with utilities included is great. Super is a nice enough guy if you can get a hold of him. Tenants are generally very friendly and it's wonderful experiencing the community within the building.
Cons:
Baseboard heat only works in some rooms, and the thermostat is just decorative and controlled by the building. Stairwells are constantly full of piss, the laundry room seems to be on its last legs. And the elevators- as soon as one is fixed the next is out of order. Packages stolen from outside of apartments, not a single person manning the front desk these days and security cameras are out of order.
11 months ago
A swing and a kiss
Former Tenant
Pros:
No positives really
Cons:
2 out of 3 broken elevators ALWAYS…. 28 floors and 1 working elevator? Not okay. Homeless in the stairwell! Called 311 to complain and management of the building said they don’t ask them to leave because they get “aggressive” pee & feces also in stairwell. “Security guard” constantly smoking weed with people in the lobby. Packages constantly being stolen. Heat cranking on in the middle of June.
Over 1 year ago
Great for what it was
Former Tenant
Pros:
Amazing location, the actual apartment has modern appliances
Cons:
The elevators, hallways, entry were all old, somewhat dirty, and chaotic. Packages would be stolen
Over 1 year ago
Run while you can
Former Tenant
Pros:
Very spacious apartments
Cons:
The building is filthy. My unit was infested with roaches, and the building manager Elizabeth would not accomodate us and help us get an exterminator. Also, water would come up through our sick drain and overflow onto the floor. Each unit has a thermostat, but sometimes the heat would not work.
Over 1 year ago
Decent experience living here
Former Tenant
Pros:
Can pay rent online, submit matinence requests online, super was friendly, trash chutes on every floor, laundry was almost always working
Cons:
Mice on almost every floor, lots people hanging out in front of the building, elevator slow
Advice to owner:
eradicate the mice
Over 1 year ago
Great place to live!
Former Tenant
Pros:
Wonderful neighbors and neighborhood! Columbia kids moving in need to actually try to be part of community.
Cons:
Elevators kept breaking down!
Advice to owner:
Fix the elevators! And the fob key!
Over 1 year ago
Terrible environment
Former Tenant
Pros:
The apartments are well laid out and renovated pretty decently. Utilities are included in the rent and many of the unites are rent stabilized. Water pressure is fine. There was more than enough heat in the winter so not only do you not get cold, you might have to sit around in shorts.
Cons:
Huge mouse problem. It took years to get the mouse problem in my apartment under control, but I knew the problem still persisted in other apartments. Lot of loiterers around the building leaving their trash everywhere. Some of the neighbors are not respectful and would leave their trash everywhere, or would hang out playing loud music and talking loudly late at night in the courtyard behind the building, so all the apartments facing the courtyard would be affected by the noise.
Advice to owner:
Hire better security to get rid of all the loiterers and non-residents that would just hang out throughout the building's hallways and non-public courtyard.
Over 1 year ago
Bedbugs, mice and roach infestation
Former Tenant
Pros:
Nothing is good
Cons:
Elevators don’t work, bed bug and roach and mice infestation Mold and water leaking from ceiling Stove don’t work Section 8 told them to fix it when they did inspection in January 2022 and they never came to fix anything
Over 1 year ago
Horrible management, broken elevators, & more
Former Tenant
Pros:
The location is great, right across the street from a park and near the trains. The inside of the apartments are decently nice. Great water pressure in the shower too.
Cons:
Terrible building management and unkept building and maintenance. The elevators never work and with so many tenants, you can wait for up to 20 minutes to get into the elevator and it will be packed with people. Management claims they are fixing the elevators but never do. There were so many times I was late for work because I had to walk down 27 flights of straits since the elevators were out. Not fun. A lot of times they were unsafe to even be in; occasionally dropping multiple floors while you’re in it and getting stuck for several minutes. The laundry is also not good. The machines rarely work or are fixed. All in all I’d just say the building is janky. And for a building of this size with so many tenants, it should absolutely be given more care. The building manager absolutely needs to be fined.
Advice to owner:
Find a new occupation.
Over 1 year ago
Colton Management is a massive slum lord
Former Tenant
Pros:
Great location by the park and subways and 125th street
Cons:
Elizabeth, the building management is useless. Had roaches for months and had to call 311 multiple times. Had a leak in our ceiling into our tub that would took 3 weeks to resolve.
Advice to owner:
Fire Elizabeth she is useless
Over 2 years ago
2021/2022 Apartment Experience
Former Tenant
Pros:
Rent controlled, laundry room, renovated unit, nice views
Cons:
Roaches, broken elevator, no one at the front desk, hard to contact managers
Over 2 years ago
Could be better
Former Tenant
Pros:
Good location to transport
Cons:
Cleanliness and the lack there of
Advice to owner:
Where’s security? We pay rent for it.
Over 2 years ago
Dog shit in the stairwell. Aggressive neighbors. Loud Parties
Former Tenant
Pros:
Nicely renovated apartments.
Cons:
No community pride. Tenants would let’s pets poop in the stairwell. Tenants would also urinate themselves in the stairwell. Deafening parties from neighbors who then would bang on door and threaten violence if anyone complained. Also deafening church across the street late at night on Sundays.
Advice to owner:
Evict problem tenants and take a stronger approach.
Over 2 years ago
Horrible living experience
Former Tenant
Pros:
I have great neighbors
Cons:
This building is disgusting. I have no heat in my apartment and it has been less than 30 degrees all week.
Advice to owner:
Take care of your tenants.
Over 2 years ago
Not my cup of tea
Former Tenant
Pros:
-laundry -close to the park and subway -electric and gas included great view of the park modern lobby
Cons:
-the elevators take forever -my hallway smelled like trash constantly -exterminator never came -I could never figure out how to buzz people in -management would never return my calls -my bathroom sinks clogged constantly, very strange -scaffolding -people don't curb their dogs when walking in front of buildings.
Advice to owner:
-fix the elevators. im serious.
Over 2 years ago
was good for a little while
Former Tenant
Pros:
unit we had was renovated with modern fixtures and nice fake wood flooring. Tons of light from the apartment
Cons:
roaches galore. bedbugs always moving from one unit to another. walls sometimes a little too thin that any argument comes through clearly. Didn't have a working key to the building for the first three months
Advice to owner:
hire more people to work in the service desk so they can be open for longer than 5 hours a day
Over 2 years ago
Better Than Most
Former Tenant
Pros:
Free to have parties and guests. No one complained about smoking marijuana in the building. Easy time doing laundry in basement. Awesome super. The unit I was in was in good condition.
Cons:
Package thieves. People smoked cigarettes in building. Hot water and heat were scarce for several months in WINTER 2020. I had called 411 so many times that a Judge accepted the case. But they claimed to have “fixed” the broken boiler a day before trial. It wasn’t fixed however. And one of the elevators broke in May 2021 and still is not working November 2021. So only two working elevators in a ginormous building. Created elevator traffic. Sometimes waiting 10-15 minutes to get on elevator. Rude manager.
Over 2 years ago
It is what it is but it ain’t great
Former Tenant
Pros:
Location, view, good community of neighbors for the most part
Cons:
Everything else is pretty bad. Management seems to want to keep everything right above where conditions would be unacceptable. They have lots of signs up and claimed to be sanitizing every floor throughout the day but this place is as filthy as ever. Local management is crabby and rude, the maintenance crew means well and are generally nice but it’s obvious they’re working under limitations they are not at liberty to mention.
Advice to owner:
Invest in the properties you already own instead of gobbling up more real estate. This place is falling apart which wouldn’t be an issue if getting maintenance to come by wasn’t such an ordeal.
Over 2 years ago
A old shell with a fresh coat of paint.
Former Tenant
Pros:
It’s the hood
Cons:
Gentrification, the building shakes.
Advice to owner:
Stop trying to get the blacks out
Over 2 years ago
Building has potential but
Former Tenant
Pros:
Laundry - but closes randomly and room is not kept clean. Location Bang for your buck
Cons:
Mgmt treats tenants poorly. Bad communication. People allowed to pee in stairwells. Security was supposed to be 24/7 and now is at random hours. Front door always breaks. Long-standing tenants have so much internal disagreement cannot even get a tenants association going.
Advice to owner:
Cameras in stairwells Clean the halls better. Laundry 24/7. Fix and allow access to community room Beautify back yard space.
Over 2 years ago
Disgusting
Former Tenant
Pros:
Views from the higher floors.
Cons:
Absolutely disgusting. There are rats and the roaches are tenants in this building. The elevator constantly breaks down and smells like pee. The security guards do not actually pay attention to who enters or exits the building. It takes almost a year for management to address ONE complaint. Avoid here if you can help it.
Advice to owner:
Do better please.
Over 2 years ago
410 St Nicholas
Former Tenant
Pros:
- huge apt - incredible views of the city - a lot of closet space - dishwasher - lots of natural sunlight - some really fantastic neighbors - Nelson, the super is very personable - laundry in basement - recycling in basement - trash shoot - across from st Nicholas park - M3 right outside your door - short walk to ABCD - overall, great apt with some major setbacks at times
Cons:
- laundry has been packed lately and half the time washers and/or dryers are out of order - not too many people wear masks in elevator - no 24 hr doorman even though there should be - multiple stolen packages - front door is taped open - some not so fantastic neighbors in building - people sleeping in hallways - hallways smell funky at times - water can be hard to come by at times (fixing pipes or just sometimes not there randomly) - drains don’t always drain the best - can take some time to get things fixed if needed especially since there are so many apts in the building - lots of building work happening lately so it can be very loud - only 2/3 elevators working (been well over 1 month now) … made it on whatisnewyork - been a handful of fires (apts are fire contained) - management office can be hard to get ahold of at times
Advice to owner:
- make sure there really is a 24 hr security - fix the elevator
Over 2 years ago
Interesting
Former Tenant
Pros:
Very very Friendly
Cons:
No heat at all
Advice to owner:
Heat should be better
Over 2 years ago
Do not live here
Former Tenant
Pros:
There are rent stabilized units in the building. All utilities (besides cable and wifi) are included in your rent. The super, Nelson, is nice. The layout of my apartment is great.
Cons:
The tenants and some employees did not follow covid 19 protocols. They were not enforced at all. Management is totally unresponsive and doesn’t care about their tenants. There was a fire in the building earlier this week and no alarms went off; I found out there was a fire from an app on my phone. The broker and management misrepresented the building’s amenities. The elevators are dirty and slow. The hallways look like something out of a Saw movie and are super echo-y. I can hear everything happening in the hallway in my apartment, as if there are no walls in place. I’ve had rodents a lot and was told that mice run down the hallways. Packages get stolen often. Elizabeth, the building manager, is supposed to be in her office during regular business hours, but she’s almost never there.
Advice to owner:
Get it together and start caring about your properties.
Over 2 years ago
Does the job
Former Tenant
Pros:
Position is amazing. I like my apartment a lot. Centralized heaters.
Cons:
There are mices and there are roaches like all the apartments in nyc.It took me 3 years to fix the mice problem,but if you’re a clean person it won’t be hard to keep roaches away. The security guard is just useless,they don’t do their job well. Laundry room is VERY dirty,and machines are often out of order but workable. 80% of the people that live in this building are RUDE AND DISRESPECTFUL. There in work in progress since I started living here and it looks like is never ending.
Advice to owner:
Management could be better but I don’t complain. Remove the scaffolding.
Over 2 years ago
Quiet floor for now
Former Tenant
Pros:
The only good thing is my floor is very quiet
Cons:
Lobby smells bad and The WATER yes WATER situation in this building is sooooo bad!! Im afraid to wash my food sometimes as the cold water is so WHITE and CLOUDY. The manager Ms.Rivera is so rude and unprofessional and they put notices night b4 for repairs with no pre warnings
Advice to owner:
Fix this stench and clean the garbage compacter daily with bleach
Submit an anonymous review to gain full access.
OR
Don't have a review to share? Subscribe to gain full access to the platform.Already have an account?Login Here