Summarized from anonymous rental reviews on openigloo.
Recent reviews for 400 West 59 Street praise its location convenience, cleanliness, friendly staff, and prompt maintenance. However, concerns include loud ongoing construction, rent increases, and occasional noise disturbances from renovations. Some tenants faced issues with central heating and unresponsive management to noisy neighbors. Despite these drawbacks, most residents appreciate the amenities like the gym and doormen. Suggestions were made for better renovation quality, improved heating systems, and more responsive management. Overall, the building appeals to those seeking a well-located luxury rental with some room for enhancement.
Reviews (13)
4.5 stars
Over 1 year ago
Overall great, but not without its faults
Former Tenant
Pros:
The location is extremely convenient, you've got easy access to the best of HK and UWS and only a 5min walk to the park. The staff are all super kind and helpful, maintenance is usually very prompt and the gym is the best apartment gym I have ever come across.
Cons:
I think this is true of all apartments in nyc but it is SO hot in winter because of the central heating, we have to have the windows open even when it's in the 30s outside.
Generally, the renovations on the apartments really give the 'landlord special' vibe - ie done cheaply and quickly - paint flecks on the walls and floor, cheap flooring, slapdash job of sealing tile, cheap HVACS etc etc. All this means we've had to get maintenance out a bunch to remedy super preventable issues that wouldn't have happened if management did a more careful job and used hardier materials.
Also if you're lucky enough to get an in unit W/D, (inexplicably) it's almost certainly going to be in the bedroom closet, which leaves you with a stuffy hot room when you're using the dryer and since there's no ventilation all that steam and moisture is getting into your clothes.
Advice to owner:
Take a more 'measure twice, cut once' philosophy to renovations
4.75 stars
Over 1 year ago
Great place to live
Former Tenant
Pros:
Location, very clean building, great doorman, handyman very helpful, great gym
Cons:
High cost, every year management increases the rent a lot.