Summarized from anonymous rental reviews on openigloo.
Recent reviews of 242 West 53 Street reveal a modern luxury building with spacious, clean units and impressive amenities such as a golf simulator, rooftop pool, and basketball court. Tenants praise the professional, responsive staff and convenient, central Midtown location. However, the building faces challenges including expensive amenity fees, occasional noise from neighbors and construction, and issues with elevator reliability. Some renters report management's slow responsiveness and security concerns due to frequent short-term tenants. Pet owners' negligence causes cleanliness issues near entrances. Overall, it suits renters seeking upscale living with extensive amenities but may not appeal to those sensitive to cost and occasional management shortcomings.
Reviews (18)
5 stars
Over 1 year ago
Luxury building in midtown
Former Tenant
Pros:
Very clean and modern, spacious unit, great amenities (golf simulator, rooftop swimming, basketball court), package room has a system
Cons:
Concierge is constantly on rotation and a lot of short term tenants, so security is a bit lax
3.38 stars
Over 2 years ago
Large Hands Off Company Luxe Apartments
Former Tenant
Pros:
Lived here for a year. The apartments are nice, we were on the ~50th floor so the noise was pretty quiet and the views were spectacular. During out time there the AC broke a few times which was frustrating but for the most part the building functioned. No vermin of any sort.
Cons:
The lobby was often messy, with the windows constantly being broken (not sure what was going on here). There were several noise complaints on our floor which the building didn't do much about. Felt like a pretty laissez faire situation.
Amenities are expensive.
Access to the rooftop costs $2500 a year per person (not per apartment), and that price doesn’t include guests. If you want to bring a guest, you have to pay $75/guest for a day pass. There is staff at the rooftop that enforces these restrictions. You can’t access any part of the rooftop without paying this fee.
Even if you pay for the rooftop, you still have to pay for the gym, which is $125/month with a minimum 1 year commitment.