Summarized from anonymous rental reviews on openigloo.
Recent reviews of 625 Caton Avenue highlight large, sunny prewar apartments with high ceilings, good heat, hot water, and strong water pressure as key benefits. The building is favorably located near parks and subway lines, with friendly neighbors. However, significant downsides include poor cleanliness, pest problems especially on lower floors, outdated and poorly maintained windows and doors, and inconsistent garbage management. Tenants report slow, sometimes confrontational superintendents and absentee or cheap landlords leading to delayed repairs and security issues. Despite spacious units and decent amenities, renters cite maintenance neglect and management unresponsiveness as detractors, urging improvements in cleanliness, pest control, and building upkeep.
Reviews (4)
2.75 stars
2 months ago
Over priced for what you get
Former Tenant
Pros:
Heat is great. Units are sunny and they’re large apartments.
Cons:
1st floor units have much more of a pest problem. Especially unit 1A which located directly above the trash room. Constant influx of roaches. The building is old and between floors is not soundproofed or insulated. You hear everything going on above you. Units are renovated periodically but only kitchens and bathrooms. Doors have been repeatedly painted over and won’t close. Windows are pretty old and busted especially the screens. Finally, very little is done to keep Galway’s and stairwells clean extremely dusty and dirty. Finally, as is usual with NYC supers this one can be very confrontational and not really proactive. Expect to wait a while to get things repaired.
Advice to owner:
KEEP IT CLEAN!!!! I could see paying what’s asked if the building were just better maintained.
3 stars
Over 2 years ago
Prewar apartments (huge rooms)
Former Tenant
Pros:
The rooms are large and not chopped up. Heat and hot water are free. The heat is kicking when it's on. I tell my friends to bring their flip-flops. Laundry place across the street with huge machines that are fast. I love the market next door. A bit pricey but they have EVERYTHING in a pinch. Close to the park, F/G and B/Q.
Cons:
The building is a co-op, where one person bought 90% of the apartments, who is cheap. Our fridge died and our new fridge is incredibly small (we have to squat to look into it/get anything out.). The landlord is brusk, but will get things moving if you call him. The super isn't hideous but isn't there best. He's a cross between the Swedish Chef from the Muppets and a Druid. It takes Jedi mind tricks, the flute of a snake charmer, and hostage negotiation skills to get him to do anything if you aren't greasing him annually. Porch pirates run a muck, despite the video cameras and new security entrance (sometimes the video works, sometimes it doesn't.). So, the landlord is attentive, but cheap with what is done. Hallways get painted every 5-8 years. Repair jobs in the apt are done by the super and his (very friendly) side kick. English is their middle language and we've had to be the middle interpreter previously when they were doing a plumbing hack job on a leaky ceiling. (We can still hear it leaking internally). Laundry machines in the basement charge extra for hot water and various cycles and are the size of a microwave. Section 8, beware. You'll be accepted, but God forbid you are late or worse. Basic human dignity will not be given to you by the super. The stories I could tell.
Advice to owner:
Pay the electric bill on time. It's not fun to come home to warnings of darkness from the electric company. Accept rent checks digitally. Get a printer and ditch the mimeograph machine. We are in a New century.
Building Ratings
Cleanliness
Garbage Management
Heat
Neighbors
Noise Levels
Owner Responsiveness
Pest Control
Water Pressure
Rents and Deposits
-- of renters received their security deposits back
It dummy text been reported if this building dummy electronic rent payments.
Open Violations
Only open violations from the last 10 years.
Data last updated 7 days ago.
The average number of violations per unit at 625 Caton Avenue is worse than the city .
BUILDING AVERAGE:
0.87 violations per unit
NEW YORK CITY AVERAGE:
0.81 violation per unit
Non-hazardous
20
class A
i.e. no peephole on a door, or no street # on the building, unlawful keeping of animals
MOST RECENT:
Jul 25, 2025: § 27-2017.3 hmc: trace and repair the source and abate the visible mold condition... less than 10 sq ft at east wall at under sink cabinet. in the kitchen located at apt 5f, 5th story, 1st apartment from east at south
Show all
Hazardous
17
class B
i.e. smoke detector issues, inadequate lighting, no lighting for stairways
MOST RECENT:
Jul 25, 2025: § 27-2005 adm code repair the broken or defective plastered surfaces and paint in a uniform color at ceiling and east wall in the 5th room from east located at apt 5f, 5th story, 1st apartment from east at south
Show all
Immediately hazardous
5
class C
i.e. rodents, pest, mold, inadequate heat or hot water, defective building parts
MOST RECENT:
Aug 06, 2023: hmc adm code: § 27-2017.4 abate the infestation consisting of roaches in the entire apartment located at apt 4e, 4th story, 1st apartment from south at west
Show all
Missing information/filings
0
class I
Missing or non-compliant with administrative information orders or filings
MOST RECENT:
No violation found...
Show all
Property Owners and Associates
D
David Katz
3.3(4)
Agent•
1 Property•48 Units
Litigation History: Yes
Evictions: 0
E
Eddie Yalcin
3.3(4)
Site Manager•
1 Property•48 Units
Litigation History: Yes
Evictions: 0
C
625 Caton Ave Owners Corp
3.3(4)
Corporate Owner•
1 Property•48 Units
Litigation History: Yes
Evictions: 0
Renter Q&A
Be the first to ask a question!
Frequently Asked Questions
Unlock insights about this building
OR
Review your building to unlock access to tenant reviews OR purchase access to unlock insights about violations, complaints, infestations, and more.