44TH Street Midtown Holdings LLC

Management was responsive and came to fix things when needed.

Windows were dirty and gym was too warm to use

Fix up the gym air

-very good hot water pressure
-very nice doormen
-amazing location
-prompt super

-hot water often goes out in the winter
-gym treadmills never fixed
-generally very dirty and smelly outside of apartment
-water goes completely out once a year for a few days
-loud traffic

doorman, location to grand central is great

repairs take a long time, things are constantly breaking down, mice in basement, mites or other bugs in bedrooms, ceilings always breaking, dishwasher not easy to use and always breaks. everything breaks!

Super convenient and the doormen are nice. Rooms are somewhat practical

Did see a mouse once; Not the cleanest; hot water fluctuates a lot - not good for colder months

Nice roof and central location.

Elevators not working regularly. Noise from pipes in the walls in middle of the night. Lack of care from management after leaks in the ceiling. Treadmills not in service for most of my time here. Management removed weights from gym. Dryers not drying clothes.

Do something about the elevators. Stop being cheap when your rent is not.

This is a fine place, but very small

Sort of like a dorm; some noisy tenants

None

Good super/building management. Prompt responses.

2 mice problems in our apt.

Rooftop, Gym, Doorman, Maintenence Responds Quickly

Units are small. I have heard of people having pest issues

Management is actively improving the building (renovated gym, new painting, etc)

Laundry room could be cleaned up. One of the two elevators is often out of order.

24 hour doorman, laundry in the building, roof

Elevator was consistently broken, neighbors had mice twice, people were squatting on one of the floors which brought sketchy people into the building, gym was dirty and gym equipment was broken.

Spend the money to permanently solve the elevator issues

There is nothing about the building that will blow you away, but there are no major negatives, which is saying a lot for an apartment building in NYC.

The elevators are down frequently and it's been 6 months since the gym was last open (they're supposedly fixing it)

Great location. Friendly doormen. Nice gym. High-end kitchen appliances.

Apartments are very small. While the renovation is great, they clearly chop the apartments up. So all rooms are tiny.

Building was well maintained and the doorman are friendly and helpful. The gym and laundry in building are nice perks as well. Anytime something was broken it was fixed promptly.

The ONE issue we had while we lived there was with mice. We had a mouse when we first moved in in September 2020, and several mice in April 2021. Each time management was helpful in getting the holes patched and providing traps but the garbage is stored in the basement which causes the mice issue.

Garbage needs to be taken out more frequently and possibly not stored in the basement.

Loved living here. Well kept place with great location

Laundry room gets crowded

Add more washers and dryers

Clean and safe

Elevator is so slow

Reach out if you have problems

The doormen are great.

Gym machines break and never are fixed.
Roof is tiny.

- Affordable
- Good location near Grand Central

- Slow elevators
- Tiny garbage chutes
- Not enough laundry machines

Good insulation, very rare to hear neighbors. Updated finishes. Nice doormen. Trash and laundry are managed well. Maintenance, pest control, package room, gym are included at no extra cost.

Management can be slow to resolve issues when they pop up (AC was main issue with this) Elevators are slow and break fairly often. Roof deck hasn’t been touched in over a year and could use some love. Windows are grimy and never cleaned.

Decent location, close to Grand Central.

Cockroaches in basement gym.
Extremely unresponsive management & super.
Most doorman to not properly manage who enters building, will not ask any questions.

Decent building w/ doorman

Awful area, apartments are way too small for the price