Turtle Bay currently has 13 apartments for rent in top rated buildings, and the most common layouts are studios and 1-bedrooms. If you are budgeting here, compare the number of bedrooms against the median rent and the unit’s actual size, since smaller layouts can still carry Midtown East pricing. Turtle Bay has an average building rating of 4.0/5 across 42 rated buildings, an average tenancy length of 1.5 months based on 7 relisted units, and an average rent increase of 15.5% based on 76 relisted units (building-level trends; individual units can differ)
Browse 13 apartments for rent in top rated buildings in Turtle Bay, Manhattan. This page helps you compare current options in a neighborhood where the median rent is $5,572, and where most homes are studios and 1-bedrooms. Openigloo adds renter-first context so you can check building reviews before you apply. Use the top rated filter to focus on higher-scoring buildings, then still confirm lease terms, fees, move-in costs, and unit-specific details with the agent.
Loading listings…
What to check when comparing top rated apartments in Turtle Bay, Manhattan
Midtown East
501 apartments
Brooklyn
147 apartments
© 2026 Openigloo Inc. All rights reserved.
Showing 1–13 of 13 listings
150 East 44 Street #38B
150 East 44 Street #PHD
150 East 44 Street #48C
150 East 44 Street #PHC