Would renters recommend 424 W 57 St, Manhattan, NY 10019?

0% of tenants who reviewed 424 W 57 St, Manhattan, NY 10019 would recommend living here.

How responsive is management at 424 W 57 St, Manhattan, NY 10019?

25% of tenants who reviewed 424 W 57 St, Manhattan, NY 10019 approve of the building's owner or management.

Does 424 W 57 St, Manhattan, NY 10019 have any open violations?

This building has 5 open violations.

Is 424 W 57 St, Manhattan, NY 10019 good cause eviction protected?

424 W 57 St, Manhattan, NY 10019 is covered by good cause eviction protections.

What are the biggest complaints about 424 W 57 St, Manhattan, NY 10019?

Tenants rated cleanliness, garbage management, owner responsiveness and pest control below average at this building.

How noisy is 424 W 57 St, Manhattan, NY 10019?

Tenants rated noise levels below average at this building.

Has 424 W 57 St, Manhattan, NY 10019 had any evictions?

This building has 1 recorded eviction.

When was 424 W 57 St, Manhattan, NY 10019 built and how many units does it have?

Built in 1910, this building has 20 units and 5 floors.

424 W 57 St

Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan, NY 10019

20 units·5 floors·Built in 1910

2.8

4 reviews

Rent-stabilized apartments

This building has apartments that entitle you to a renewal and limited rent increases.

Good cause building

This building guarantees a renewal and capped rent increases, if you follow your lease terms.

Highlights

Evictions

Open violations

Building ratings

Cleanliness

Trash management

Pest control

Water pressure

Heat

Neighbors

Noise levels

Owner responsiveness

Cleanliness

Trash management

Pest control

Water pressure

Heat

Neighbors

Noise levels

Owner responsiveness

Rents and deposits

Renters received their security deposits back

Electronic rent payments

Photos of 424 W 57 St

Open violations

From past 10 years · Updated 3 days ago

Average violations per unit in this building is better than the city average.

Building average0.25Violations per unit

NYC average0.81Violations per unit

Renter Q&A

Be the first to ask a question!

FAQs

Review 424 W 57 St

Reviews are anonymous and could truly help the next renter that considers this building.

Review 424 W 57 St

Reviews are anonymous and could truly help the next renter that considers this building.

About 424 W 57 St

424 W 57 St is a modestly reviewed but soundly run building. Tenants rate it 2.8/5 across 4 reviews, with 0% recommending it and 25% approving of the owner. It records 1 eviction, 5 open violations, and 0 litigation cases. Data last updated October 23, 2026. Built in 1910, this 5-floor building at 424 W 57 St in Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan has 20 units and is managed by M 57 LLC. This building has apartments that entitle you to a renewal and limited rent increases. Hell's Kitchen is a residential area of Manhattan. The 1, A, C, B, and D subway lines are close by, providing service along the west side of Manhattan. As a pre-war building, it reflects the mid-rise construction typical of the era in Manhattan. Prospective renters can find building ratings, reviews, and open-data records on the building page.

Review summary

Summarized from anonymous rental reviews on Openigloo.

Recent reviews for 424 W 57 St in Manhattan, NY, reflect mixed sentiments. Tenants appreciate the location's affordability and nearby amenities. However, challenges like outdated appliances, unresponsive owners, pest infestations, and maintenance issues have been highlighted. Suggestions include prompt upgrades, better landlord communication, and urgent pest control measures. While some approve of the owner, the general recommendation to stay in the building is low due to various concerns. Advancements in aesthetics and upkeep could significantly enhance residents' overall experience.

Reviews of 424 W 57 St

Former tenant·10 months ago

Decent building in HK

Pros

Reasonably priced for the location

Cons

Appliances are old

Advice to the owners

Keep up with upgrades

Former tenant·Over 1 year ago

A nice spot but with many caveats

Pros

-Amazing location -Super is a great guy and is always around -Neighbors are 25-40 -Right near central park -Solid floor layout -Not a single bug ever

Cons

-The owner cant be bothered to replace the double panel windows with a broken seal. This resulted in opaque windows of what would otherwise be a good view. -Extremely stingy landlord. Been using a half-broken fridge this entire stay. -Landlord doesnt reply to e-mails, texts, or seemingly anything. -Wood flooring means you better hope your neighbors take their shoes off inside. My neighbor records Tiktoks all day. It is not fun.

Advice to the owners

Care more about aesthetic, you could charge 25% more if you did. No passion/care/love in this apartment.

424 W 57 St

Highlights

Building ratings

Rents and deposits

Photos of 424 W 57 St

Open violations

Renter Q&A

FAQs

Review 424 W 57 St

Review 424 W 57 St

424 W 57 St

What this building's record says

About 424 W 57 St

Renter recommendations

Review summary

Reviews of 424 W 57 St

Decent building in HK

Pros

Cons

Advice to the owners

A nice spot but with many caveats

Pros

Cons

Advice to the owners

Building owners and associates

M 57 Llc

Maria Sacchetti

Michael Sacchetti

M 57 Llc

Maria Sacchetti

Michael Sacchetti