Summarized from anonymous rental reviews on openigloo.
Recent reviews for 1520 Story Avenue reveal a mixed living experience. Some tenants praise the building's cleanliness, gym facilities, and responsive maintenance team, describing it as a nice, well-managed place with friendly staff. However, others report serious issues such as persistent elevator outages, poor garbage management, pest infestations, and disrespectful superintendent behavior. Noise levels vary, with complaints about thin walls and disruptive neighbors. Water pressure and heating quality also receive inconsistent feedback. Security concerns arise due to package theft and unreliable camera systems. Overall, while there are positive aspects, significant management and maintenance improvements are needed for a consistently comfortable living environment.
Reviews (3)
1.25 stars
3 months ago
1520 is a dump! Starting with the Superintendent Juan Garcia. He’s a creep!
Former Tenant
Pros:
The maintenance guys are pleasant. (Jr. & the other guy) Hector (the repair man) is nice. Javier is ok.
Cons:
The elevator is always out of order. 1of the 2 has been out for 3 months & counting. Packages are stolen daily. The stairs are filthy. The lobby smells like cat urine. The superintendent (Juan) is disrespectful and nonchalant about repairs. He flirts with me and other tenants. The cameras only work when Juan says so. The water always shuts off.
Advice to owner:
Have compassion for the tenants who actually pay rent. We need a new superintendent!!
4.5 stars
Over 2 years ago
Very clean and nice
Former Tenant
Pros:
Most of everything
Cons:
The water pressure
Advice to owner:
Change your showers
Building Ratings
Cleanliness
Garbage Management
Heat
Neighbors
Noise Levels
Owner Responsiveness
Pest Control
Water Pressure
Rents and Deposits
-- of renters received their security deposits back
It dummy text been reported if this building dummy electronic rent payments.
Open Violations
Only open violations from the last 10 years.
Data last updated 12 hours ago.
The average number of violations per unit at 1520 Story Avenue is better than the city.
BUILDING AVERAGE:
Less than 0.01 violations per unit
NEW YORK CITY AVERAGE:
0.81 violation per unit
Non-hazardous
0
class A
i.e. no peephole on a door, or no street # on the building, unlawful keeping of animals
MOST RECENT:
No violation found...
Show all
Hazardous
0
class B
i.e. smoke detector issues, inadequate lighting, no lighting for stairways
MOST RECENT:
No violation found...
Show all
Immediately hazardous
1
class C
i.e. rodents, pest, mold, inadequate heat or hot water, defective building parts
MOST RECENT:
Aug 13, 2025: § 27-2005, 27-2007, 27-2041.1 hmc, §238, § 309; § 107 (2) ( c) mdl and 28 rcny §25-171: replace or repair the self-closing doors that is missing or defective hinges at door at laundry room, 1st story
Show all
Missing information/filings
0
class I
Missing or non-compliant with administrative information orders or filings
MOST RECENT:
No violation found...
Show all
Property Owners and Associates
S
Storyavenuewest Affordablellc
3.3(3)
Shareholder•
1 Property•446 Units
Litigation History: No
Evictions: 6
A
Adam Nadel
3.4(9)
Officer•
4 Properties•1278 Units
Litigation History: Yes
Evictions: 23
J
Juan Garcia
3.3(3)
Site Manager•
1 Property•446 Units
Litigation History: No
Evictions: 12
N
Nelson Management Group Ltd
3.3(56)
Corporate Owner•
22 Properties•4249 Units
Litigation History: Yes
Evictions: 131
Renter Q&A
Be the first to ask a question!
Frequently Asked Questions
Unlock insights about this building
OR
Review your building to unlock access to tenant reviews OR purchase access to unlock insights about violations, complaints, infestations, and more.