Pretty good with some quirks
Pros
Clean, nice doormen, lots of space, pretty good noise isolation between units
Cons
Really thin windows that let in a lot of street noise and cold
Overall good place to live
Pros
Management could be more responsive and proactive but far from the worst landlords you'll find in NYC. Building is overall very clean with decent amenities, having doormen is a nice plus and all of them are very friendly. Some of our neighbors don't know how to properly sort their recycling in the bins on each floor, but on the upside, it's nice to have recycling bins / trash shoots on each floor.
Cons
The roof has been "under refurbishment" since we moved here four years ago and management still won't allow people up there. Our super is friendly and good at his job but he's one guy and he's often swamped overseeing the entire building. Elevators don't break down very often but they're glitchy; weirdly you'll often get down to the ground floor faster if you press the "up" arrow, and vice versa.