Openigloo home
Openigloo home

Follow us

For renters

Apartments for rent in NYCRenting tips and resourcesNYC rental market guidesVerified apartment listings in NYCBuildings and owners in NYCOwners in NYCNYC market analysis reports

For landlords

iglooIQListings quality policy

Trending neighborhoods

Apartments in AstoriaApartments in Bedford-StuyvesantApartments in BushwickApartments in ChelseaApartments in Financial DistrictApartments in SohoApartments in Upper East SideApartments in Upper West SideApartments in West VillageApartments in Williamsburg

NYC boroughs

Apartments in BronxApartments in BrooklynApartments in ManhattanApartments in QueensApartments in Staten Island

2-bedroom apartments

2-bedroom apartments in Bronx2-bedroom apartments in Brooklyn2-bedroom apartments in Manhattan2-bedroom apartments in Queens2-bedroom apartments in Staten Island

Support

FAQContact usLive support

Legal

Terms of usePrivacy policyCommunity guidelinesAgency disclosureFair housing disclosureStandard operating procedures
© 2026 Openigloo Inc. All rights reserved.
P

Pennachio, Shelley

Owner·1 building·2 units
2.8

3 reviews

Highlights

No
Evictions
No
Litigation cases

About Pennachio, Shelley

Pennachio, Shelley is a modestly rated but responsible owner. Across their buildings, tenants rate them 2.8/5 across 3 reviews, with 0% recommending their buildings and 0% approving of them as an owner or associate. Their portfolio records 0 evictions, 0 open violations, and 0 litigation cases. Data last updated October 28, 2026. Shelley Pennachio is an owner associated with 1 building and 2 units located in Windsor Terrace, Brooklyn. The portfolio is concentrated in Windsor Terrace in Brooklyn. Built in 1910, the building is mostly low-rise. None of the associated units have rent-stabilized apartments. Building-level ratings, reviews, and open-data records are available on the associated building pages.

Renter recommendations

-%

Renters recommend associated buildings

-%

Renters approve of this owner or associate

Review summary

Summarized from anonymous rental reviews on Openigloo.

Tenant reviews for buildings managed by Shelley Pennachio illustrate a troubling experience. While some residents appreciate the beautiful neighborhood and friendly neighbors, numerous complaints point to significant management issues. Tenants report concerns about the owner's aggressive behavior, including invasion of privacy and harassment. Cleanliness and garbage management are inconsistent, and many renters experienced inadequate heat and pest problems. Owner responsiveness is often criticized as lacking. Overall, potential renters should approach these properties with caution, as the negative experiences and management style raise serious red flags about living conditions.

Reviews

Former tenant·31 minutes ago

Worst landlady imaginable

Pros

Beautiful neighborhood, lovely neighbors

Cons

Word limit too low to communicate how insane the landlady is. She chased out two of my roommates before chasing me out too and from asking around she has a reputation for harassing tenants and neighbors alike. Her insanity culminated in her screaming at me and my roommate at 11:30pm, entering the unit against our wishes, and threatening to physically destroy an air conditioner unit. You can expect no privacy; she monitors the building with security cameras and has commented about the time I’ve come home at night and the overnight guests I’ve had. Several times I’ve discovered her picking through my garbage. She does not recognize any boundaries and called me insane for asserting my basic rights to privacy as a tenant. Hopefully you discover these reviews before renting (I wish I had myself!) and stay far, far away. It’s really a shame, because it’s such a lovely apartment—I was willing to put up with a lot to stay there, but it’s too much for anyone to handle.

Former tenant·Over 1 year ago

STEER CLEAR OF THIS APARTMENT

Pros

Not much can make up for the cons.

Cons

This is a cursed property that you should avoid at all costs. Let this be a warning! Anyone that gives this property a good review is aligned with the LL and part of their web of lies and deceit. Those closest to the LL should break the cycle of hurt and suffering caused by the LL that is a result of some type of trauma. It is a sad situation and best not to get involved.

Advice to the owners

LL should promptly seek professional mental health support.

Buildings associated with PENNACHIO, SHELLEY

  • 302 Windsor Place

    302 Windsor Place

    2.8(3)

    Windsor Terrace

302 Windsor Place

302 Windsor Place

2.8(3)

Windsor Terrace

Building ratings

Cleanliness

-

Trash management

-

Pest control

-

Water pressure

-

Heat

-

Neighbors

-

Noise levels

-

Owner responsiveness

-

Cleanliness

-

Trash management

-

Pest control

-

Water pressure

-

Heat

-

Neighbors

-

Noise levels

-

Owner responsiveness

-

Rents and deposits

-

Renters received their security deposits back

-

Electronic rent payments

Open violations

From past 10 years · Updated 5 days ago

Average violations per unit for this owner or associate is better than the city average.

Owner averageLess than 0.01Violations per unit
NYC average0.81Violations per unit
0Class C
Immediately hazardous

Rodents, pest, mold, inadequate heat or hot water, defective building parts

0Class B
Hazardous

Smoke detector issues, inadequate lighting, no lighting for stairways

0Class A
Non-hazardous

No peephole on a door, no street number on the building, unlawful keeping of animals

0Class I
Missing info

Missing or non-compliant with administrative information orders or filings

FAQs

Pennachio, Shelley has an average tenant rating of 2.8 out of 5 across 3 reviews.

0% of tenants who reviewed buildings managed by Pennachio, Shelley would recommend living there.

Pennachio, Shelley has no housing court litigation cases across their portfolio.

Pennachio, Shelley has no recorded evictions across their portfolio.

Pennachio, Shelley owns or manages 1 building totalling 2 units.

0% of tenants who reviewed a building managed by Pennachio, Shelley approve of how it is run.

Pennachio, Shelley has not appeared on the NYC worst landlords list.

P

Pennachio, Shelley

Owner·1 building·2 units
2.8

3 reviews

Follow us

For renters

Apartments for rent in NYCRenting tips and resourcesNYC rental market guidesVerified apartment listings in NYCBuildings and owners in NYCOwners in NYCNYC market analysis reports

For landlords

iglooIQListings quality policy

Trending neighborhoods

Apartments in AstoriaApartments in Bedford-StuyvesantApartments in BushwickApartments in ChelseaApartments in Financial DistrictApartments in SohoApartments in Upper East SideApartments in Upper West SideApartments in West VillageApartments in Williamsburg

NYC boroughs

Apartments in BronxApartments in BrooklynApartments in ManhattanApartments in QueensApartments in Staten Island

2-bedroom apartments

2-bedroom apartments in Bronx2-bedroom apartments in Brooklyn2-bedroom apartments in Manhattan2-bedroom apartments in Queens2-bedroom apartments in Staten Island

Support

FAQContact usLive support

Legal

Terms of usePrivacy policyCommunity guidelinesAgency disclosureFair housing disclosureStandard operating procedures
© 2026 Openigloo Inc. All rights reserved.