Pros:
Gym, roof, views, price, cleanliness, doormen, safety, proximity to Riverside and Central park, online portal makes everything easy to manage, co-working spaces.
Cons:
Far from subway, M12 and M57 buses take awhile and are irregular, roof closes at 1030pm, some neighbors are dirty (but still kind and courteous), people smoke in the stairwell (although management has tried to crack down)