Carnegie Hill Properties

Corporate Owner

•

1 Properties

•

179 Units

•

4.1(6)

Evictions: 0

Litigation History: Yes

Review Summary for Carnegie Hill Properties

Summarized from anonymous rental reviews on openigloo.

Tenants of Carnegie Hill Properties report a mixed experience regarding management. Positive feedback highlights well-kept buildings, attentive doormen, quick issue resolution, and convenient locations with good amenities. However, concerns include inconsistent responsiveness from management, unresolved maintenance problems such as water discoloration and appliance issues, and occasional attempts at unexpected charges. Some residents describe management as slow or difficult to communicate with, with frustrations over rent increases and building cleanliness. Prospective renters should expect a generally attractive building with competent service, though preparedness for occasional management delays and higher rent costs may be necessary.

Open Violations

Only open violations from the last 10 years.

Data last updated 6 days ago.

The average number of violations per unit for this owner/associates across their portfolio is better than the city.

BUILDING AVERAGE:

0.07 violations per unit

NEW YORK CITY AVERAGE:

0.81 violation per unit

Non-hazardous

class A

i.e. no peephole on a door, or no street # on the building, unlawful keeping of animals

MOST RECENT:

May 14, 2024: § 27-2005 hmc: properly repair or replace the broken or defective wall cabinet at west in the kitchen located at apt 3c, 3rd story, 2nd apartment from south at west

Show all

Hazardous

class B

i.e. smoke detector issues, inadequate lighting, no lighting for stairways

MOST RECENT:

Sep 06, 2024: § 27-2005 adm code & 309 m/d law abate the nuisance consisting of bathroom shelving covering half of bathtub in the bathroom located at apt 3c, 3rd story, 2nd apartment from south at west

Show all

Immediately hazardous

class C

i.e. rodents, pest, mold, inadequate heat or hot water, defective building parts

MOST RECENT:

May 14, 2024: hmc adm code: § 27-2017.4 abate the infestation consisting of roaches in the entire apartment located at apt 3c, 3rd story, 2nd apartment from south at west

Show all

Missing information/filings

class I

Missing or non-compliant with administrative information orders or filings

MOST RECENT:

No violation found...

Show all

All Properties Associated with Carnegie Hill Properties

All Upper West Side

154 West 70 Street, Manhattan, NY 10023

179 Units • 12 Floors

4.1(6)

Rent Stabilized Units: Yes

Good Cause Eviction: Yes

Evictions: 0

Litigation History: Yes

1 Year Bedbug History: No

Reviews (6)

3 months ago

Brown hot water

Former Tenant

Pros:

Elevator, good sized apartments

Cons:

I had a constant issue with the hot water being completely brown in this building. I lived in two units and both had the same issue. The building would not give me a rent concession while the issue persisted (the issue was never resolved)

8 months ago

Nice luxury building on the upper west side

Former Tenant

Pros:

Great doormen and service, gym & rooftop access. Ideal location on the Upper West Side, very convenient & close to public transit

Cons:

Big rent increases year after year, especially for small space

Over 3 years ago

Condescending Super Pretty Building

Former Tenant

Pros:

Pretty common areas, except for floor hallways.

Cons:

The Super was annoying to work with. He would deny issues existed. Our freezer would have sheets of ice at the bottom and eventually leak all over the floor. He refused to fix it/replace it. And said it’s something we should deal with.

Over 3 years ago

Nice building and nice staff

Former Tenant

Pros:

Everything is well kepts

Cons:

Elevator goes out every once in a while

Advice to owner:

Keep it up

Over 4 years ago

good clean building

Former Tenant

Pros:

quiet, well maintained. any issues arise they come to a solution/fix quickly.

Cons:

rent, try to squeeze as much as they can when you come to re-new.

Over 4 years ago

Lipstick on a pig

Former Tenant

Pros:

The building looks amazing at first pass through (but it’s not) and the location is great.

Cons:

Terrible terrible terrible management. I’ve been in nyc over a decade, worst building I’ve lived in! Barely clean. They try to sneak in charges all the time. The landlord is truly a bad person, nickel and dimes. Takes weeks for management to respond. I had to call a lawyer to email them to fix my broken heat! Highly recommend literally anywhere else.