Mccallister Management LLC

Corporate Owner

•

Agent

•

16 Properties

•

101 Units

•

3.5(15)

Evictions: 3

Litigation History: Yes

Review Summary for Mccallister Management LLC

Summarized from anonymous rental reviews on openigloo.

Recent tenant feedback for MCCALLISTER MANAGEMENT LLC buildings reveals a mixed experience. While many buildings feature modern designs, updated appliances, and convenient amenities like keyless entry and roof decks, frequent complaints focus on slow owner responsiveness and inconsistent maintenance. Noise from neighbors and construction, poor garbage management, and occasional pest issues also affect satisfaction. Some residents report unclean common areas and management's inadequate handling of disruptive tenants. However, when management is responsive, tenants appreciate their attentiveness and find the living environment pleasant with good neighbors. Overall, management could improve timely communication and upkeep to elevate tenant satisfaction.

Open Violations

Only open violations from the last 10 years.

Data last updated 7 days ago.

The average number of violations per unit for this owner/associates across their portfolio is better than the city.

BUILDING AVERAGE:

0.4 violations per unit

NEW YORK CITY AVERAGE:

0.81 violation per unit

Non-hazardous

class A

i.e. no peephole on a door, or no street # on the building, unlawful keeping of animals

MOST RECENT:

Sep 14, 2019: § 27-2005 adm code refit door in the entrance located at apt 3, 3rd story

Show all

Hazardous

class B

i.e. smoke detector issues, inadequate lighting, no lighting for stairways

MOST RECENT:

Sep 13, 2025: § 27-2017.3 hmc: trace and repair the source and abate the visible mold condition... less than 10 square feet at north wall in the 3rd room from north located at apt 5, 3rd story, 2nd apartment from south at west original violation 17897498 issued 12-may-25 has been upgraded to class b per administrative code 27-2017.3a(3)(a) or (b).

Show all

Immediately hazardous

class C

i.e. rodents, pest, mold, inadequate heat or hot water, defective building parts

MOST RECENT:

Nov 28, 2024: § 27-2033 adm code provide ready access to buildings heating system door locked at boiler room

Show all

Missing information/filings

class I

Missing or non-compliant with administrative information orders or filings

MOST RECENT:

No violation found...

Show all

All Properties Associated with Mccallister Management LLC

East Village

176 1 Avenue, Manhattan, NY 10009

Units • Floors

0(0)

Rent Stabilized Units: Unknown

Good Cause Eviction: Yes

Evictions: 0

Litigation History: No

1 Year Bedbug History: No

Cobble Hill

92 Atlantic Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11201

12 Units • 5 Floors

1.8(1)

Rent Stabilized Units: Unknown

Good Cause Eviction: Yes

Evictions: 0

Litigation History: Yes

1 Year Bedbug History: No

Chelsea

231 West 20 Street, Manhattan, NY 10011

10 Units • 3 Floors

3.2(3)

Rent Stabilized Units: Unknown

Evictions: 0

Litigation History: Yes

1 Year Bedbug History: No

Cobble Hill

90 Atlantic Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11201

10 Units • 4 Floors

0(0)

Rent Stabilized Units: Yes

Good Cause Eviction: Yes

Evictions: 0

Litigation History: No

1 Year Bedbug History: No

Reviews (15)

4 months ago

Terrible tenants and building manager

Former Tenant

Pros:

Nice new building

Cons:

Inconsiderate tenants, constant roof parties with loud music, leave messy and expect others to pick up after them. Building management does not care.

Advice to owner:

Manage your tenants, stop the loud roof parties

7 months ago

231 W 20th St

Former Tenant

Pros:

New apartment and appliances
quiet street
Central air
elevator to each floor and nice roof deck

Cons:

Constant issues with equipment breaking
management was slow to fix

Advice to owner:

Quicker response to issues

8 months ago

Unicorn Apartment-Loved living here!

Former Tenant

Pros:

Updated appliances. Gutted and redone so it feels new and clean while still having some charm of a prewar building. Love the neighborhood.

Cons:

Management takes awhile to respond.

Advice to owner:

Better way to contact Management

Over 1 year ago

Shiny Facade, Shoddy Reality: A Disappointing New Apartment Building

Former Tenant

Pros:

• New building
• Nice-looking finishes (though cheaply done)

Cons:

• Poor construction quality
• Thin walls allowing excessive noise transmission
• Unresponsive management
• Frequent maintenance issues and malfunctioning fixtures/appliances
• Poorly designed floor plan that wastes space
• Cheap execution of finishes despite attractive appearance

Over 1 year ago

Pretty Good Place In Decent Spot

Former Tenant

Pros:

Structure nice, modern ish, large stoop, keyless access, good lighting.

Cons:

Cockroaches in basement often, some mold in moist places

Advice to owner:

Faster maintenance

Over 2 years ago

Management are super helpful

Former Tenant

Pros:

The building is beautiful. There were some minor issues we experienced but the management team was quick to address them.

Cons:

I wish they left the grills on through the winter.

Over 2 years ago

Nice building but horrible management

Former Tenant

Pros:

Big windows and kitchen

Cons:

bad management - constant trash on the roof and vomit on the stairs. also did not have hot water for 3~4 days

Over 2 years ago

Pretty Good Building

Former Tenant

Pros:

Building feels well built. The unit is spacious and sturdy. Walls are thick so I've never gotten a noise complaint. Neighbors have to be blasting music for me to hear anything, and even when that's happened it's been fairly muffled and quiet. Fair trade for my own freedom. The building kind of feels like a bunker, which is nice if you get overwhelmed by the city. Management was fairly attentive and the super is very nice.

Cons:

Expensive units = wealthy neighbors, so the neighbors can be entitled. The super constantly had to unclog the trash chute because the neighbors carelessly threw un-bagged garbage down the chute. Also, the building is on First Ave which can be loud and hectic.

Over 2 years ago

Worst service I have experienced in renting

Former Tenant

Pros:

There's not too much to like. The location is good, but it can get loud.

Cons:

Maintenance and support. There's a lack of service when you need something. I had to call 311 multiple times until they got back to me.

Advice to owner:

Literally respond to email, texts, and calls. Don't complain about parties calling 311 to report you and ask us not to call 311 to solve.

Over 2 years ago

Great apartment with minor inconveniences

Former Tenant

Pros:

Well maintained stairway. Modern aesthetic. Very little rent increase. Great neighborhood, responsive management

Cons:

Gym is not well maintained (has a lot of flies). Packages can pileup very fast. Water heating is slow, water pressure is okay, appliances are not too efficient. Sink buildup because it's flat / a lot of form over function. My unit has little sunlight. Far from train and Atlantic Ave has too many car collisions

Advice to owner:

Fix minor issues and the only con would be that this is a walk-up

Over 3 years ago

Great experience

Former Tenant

Pros:

Nice appliances and furnishing, amazing roof deck, fun neighbors. Good vibes

Cons:

We had mice

Advice to owner:

Try to get rid of the mice

Over 3 years ago

Convenient but appearance not a priority for owners

Former Tenant

Pros:

Latch app for building and apartment access is very convenient. Maintenance is friendly and responsive.

Cons:

The common areas (hallways, back patio) aren’t kept up well. The back patio was advertised as a common gathering area, but in reality is a dirty, unpleasant area where trash and recycling bins are that butts up against a construction site.

Advice to owner:

Clean up the common areas and don’t paint dark hallways dark colors.

Over 3 years ago

Quiet, Clean Apartment in Crown Heights

Former Tenant

Pros:

Management is responsive to issues, nice appliances and finishes, Latch electronic key system, beautiful hardwood floors, A/C and heat units.

Cons:

Apartment was not as clean from the last tenant as it should have been and many things were broken upon move in. However, these issues were resolved by maintenance pretty quickly.

Advice to owner:

Upkeep of the front of the apartment could be better.

Over 4 years ago

Good building and management

Former Tenant

Pros:

Beautiful furnishings. Well maintained. Good management

Cons:

Extremely loud construction of hospital 10 feet away from building

Over 4 years ago

Well worth the $ if you loke coliving

Former Tenant

Pros:

New appliances. 2nd floor is comfortable in summer.
No lease.
Gym included
apartment cleaning included

Cons:

One fridge for 6 people.
Some closets and doors get stuck.
Bathroom tile grout is orange.

Advice to owner:

Pretty good building