Pros:
The apartment was spacious, the sound insulation was decent (besides having a very loud neighbor move in briefly). Everything was pretty much in working order and the neighborhood/street is great.
Cons:
Nothing to do with the landlords, but there was a period where some loud neighbors moved in. We never confronted them about it, or complained, so I can’t really hold anyone accountable for that except the said neighbors. Before that and after it was a very quiet building. There were never any severe issues with pests, but like any NYC building, you do have to be defensive about roaches. The apartments are advertised as a 2bedroom but they’re railroad style, so for a roommate situation it could be inconvenient.
Advice to owner:
Install a security camera outside.
Warn new tenants about noise levels, super loud bass systems (that they may disturb existing tenants).