What do tenants say about Nicholas Cataldo?

Nicholas Cataldo has an average tenant rating of 4.1 out of 5 across 24 reviews.

How many violations does Nicholas Cataldo have across their portfolio?

Buildings managed by Nicholas Cataldo average 0.97 open violations per unit, more than the citywide average of 0.81.

Would renters recommend buildings managed by Nicholas Cataldo?

84% of tenants who reviewed buildings managed by Nicholas Cataldo would recommend living there.

Is Nicholas Cataldo responsive to tenants?

84% of tenants who reviewed a building managed by Nicholas Cataldo approve of how it is run.

Is Nicholas Cataldo on the worst landlords list?

Nicholas Cataldo has not appeared on the NYC worst landlords list.

Has Nicholas Cataldo had any evictions?

Nicholas Cataldo has no recorded evictions across their portfolio.

Has Nicholas Cataldo had any litigation cases?

Nicholas Cataldo has 2 housing court litigation cases across their portfolio.

How many buildings does Nicholas Cataldo own or manage?

Nicholas Cataldo owns or manages 1 building totalling 36 units.

Nicholas Cataldo

Agent·1 building·36 units

4.1

24 reviews

Highlights

Evictions

Litigation cases

About Nicholas Cataldo

Nicholas Cataldo is a mixed-profile agent. Across their buildings, tenants rate them 4.1/5 across 24 reviews, with 84% recommending their buildings and 84% approving of them as an owner or associate. Their portfolio records 0 evictions, 35 open violations, and 2 litigation cases. Data last updated August 23, 2026. Across the All Upper West Side in Manhattan, Nicholas Cataldo is an agent associated with 1 building and 36 units. The portfolio is concentrated in the All Upper West Side neighborhood of Manhattan. The building was constructed in the 1920s and is primarily mid-rise. None of the associated units are rent-stabilized. Building-level ratings, reviews, and open-data records are available on the associated building pages.

Renter recommendations

Renters recommend associated buildings

Renters approve of this owner or associate

Building photos

Review summary

Summarized from anonymous rental reviews on Openigloo.

Recent reviews for buildings managed by Nicholas Cataldo indicate a mixed experience for tenants. Many highlight the well-maintained cleanliness and friendly neighbors, particularly in Columbia student-heavy areas. However, there are consistent concerns about heat management issues, security for packages, and varying responsiveness of management. While most praise certain staff for their helpfulness, others have faced unresponsive superintendents. Renters suggest improvements in organizational efficiency and heightened security measures. Despite these drawbacks, the generally favorable atmosphere and strategic locations make these properties appealing for those prioritizing convenience and community, especially for students.

Reviews

Former tenant·3 months ago

nice building to live in

Pros

nice neighbors, not to loud, good location

Cons

organization could have been better and my roommate lost a package although it may not have been the buildings fault

Former tenant·Over 1 year ago

Not the worst

Pros

location is not bad, close to train is great. elevator is nice (but was out for months when i lived there for renovation)

Cons

major issues with front door/gate that went completely ignored by super and my unit owner. getting security deposit back was a nightmare owner kept playing games. didn't have heat for weeks in winter. super is not helpful and rude. saw a dead rat on the 2nd floor hallway once.

Advice to the owners

sell it to someone who might put effort into being a landlord

Buildings associated with NICHOLAS CATALDO

Good cause
205 W 103 St
4.1(24)
All Upper West Side

Good cause

205 W 103 St

4.1(24)

All Upper West Side

Building ratings

Cleanliness

Trash management

Pest control

Water pressure

Heat

Neighbors

Noise levels

Owner responsiveness

Cleanliness

Trash management

Pest control

Water pressure

Heat

Neighbors

Noise levels

Owner responsiveness

Rents and deposits

Renters received their security deposits back

Electronic rent payments

Open violations

From past 10 years · Updated 5 days ago

Average violations per unit for this owner or associate is worse than the city average.

Owner average0.97Violations per unit

NYC average0.81Violations per unit

2Class C

Immediately hazardous

Rodents, pest, mold, inadequate heat or hot water, defective building parts

29Class B

Hazardous

Smoke detector issues, inadequate lighting, no lighting for stairways

4Class A

Non-hazardous

No peephole on a door, no street number on the building, unlawful keeping of animals

0Class I

Missing info

Missing or non-compliant with administrative information orders or filings

FAQs