Sheepshead Bay currently has 12 apartments for rent, and the most common unit sizes are 1-bedrooms and 2-bedrooms. If you're budgeting here, those bedroom types are the most useful starting point for comparing rent against space. The current median rent is $3,529. Use that as a benchmark, but still check building-level reviews, lease terms, and move-in costs before you apply (building-level trends; individual units can differ).
Browse 12 apartments for rent in Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn. This page helps you compare current options in the neighborhood and narrow by the basics that matter most: rent, bedroom count, and building details. Openigloo adds renter-first context such as building reviews and landlord signals so you can screen before you tour. In Sheepshead Bay, the current median rent is $3,529, so it helps to compare asking rent against the full move-in cost, not just the monthly number.
Loading listings…
What to check when comparing apartments in Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn
Downtown Brooklyn
261 apartments
Gravesend
27 apartments
3,359 apartments
© 2026 Openigloo Inc. All rights reserved.
Showing 1–12 of 12 listings
3280 Nostrand Avenue #614
3280 Nostrand Avenue #102
1524 Sheepshead Bay Road #14F
1524 Sheepshead Bay Road #9H