Absolutely fine
Pros
Convenient location, pretty walk-up, newish appliances, no roaches / rats
Cons
No light in the living room, tiny kitchen, bad ventilation, water heater was broken for weeks and not fixed
Advice to the owners
Improve response rate
Average Murray Hill building
Pros
Top floor has access to rooftop and thai restuarant at the bottom slaps
Cons
Stairs, no natural light