Midtown, Manhattan, NY 10019
24 reviews
Top rated building
This building is highly reviewed and rated 4+ stars by past and current renters.
Rent-stabilized apartments
This building has apartments that entitle you to a renewal and limited rent increases.
Good cause building
This building guarantees a renewal and capped rent increases, if you follow your lease terms.
Cleanliness
Trash management
Pest control
Water pressure
Heat
Neighbors
Noise levels
Owner responsiveness
Cleanliness
Trash management
Pest control
Water pressure
Heat
Neighbors
Noise levels
Owner responsiveness
Renters received their security deposits back
Electronic rent payments
From past 10 years · Updated a day ago
Average violations per unit in this building is better than the city average.
Which amenities are there in the building ?
Over 3 years ago
Midtown, Manhattan, NY 10019
4.4
24 reviews
Violations, complaints, infestations, and more — pulled from official data. Unlock insights to see the full report.
Already have an account?
Renters recommend this building
Renters approve of the building's owners
Summarized from anonymous rental reviews on Openigloo.
Do you own or manage 211 W 56 St?
Respond to tenant reviewsExcellent staff and location.
Bathrooms a bit dated
Carnegie Mews was my first apartment that I lived in NYC and I really enjoyed living here. First of all, the apartment is very well maintained. management was very responsive to any issues and promptly followed up .I love the lobby - I always enjoyed greeting the doormen when I returned home. - My apartment feels very spacious by NYC standards. A lot of closet space and a giant living room with a direct view into Times Square. I loved my apartment! - Good AC in the summer, heat in the winter - (ESA) pet friendly. Lots of furry friends in the building!
The apartment is very expensive and they do raise the rent quite significantly each quarter. When I moved in, my apartment was 4625. When I moved out, they had planned to renew to 4850, That's an extra 2400 a month - wild. Building has little to no amenities. Paying an arm and a leg for a singular apartment, a nice lobby, and doormen. I think you're mainly paying for the location. Building is a bit old and my drain frequently clogged despite our best efforts Elevator (particularly to the higher floors) often stopped working. This past year alone, stopped working 4 times.
Lovely apartment building and honestly if I could afford it, I wouldn't have moved out. Still, some may argue that you don't really get your moneys worth due to the lack of amenities. Personally, I think all the space in my unit made up for it!
Rodents, pest, mold, inadequate heat or hot water, defective building parts
Smoke detector issues, inadequate lighting, no lighting for stairways
No peephole on a door, no street number on the building, unlawful keeping of animals
Missing or non-compliant with administrative information orders or filings