Openigloo home

Affordable buildings near the 5 train in Sutton Place

Sutton Place is a Manhattan neighborhood where renters often look for steady access to Midtown via nearby subway options. This page focuses on buildings that match the 5-train + market-relative affordable filter pair. For Sutton Place, rated buildings have an average building rating of 3.7/5 across 43 rated buildings. (building-level trends; individual units can differ)

Affordable buildings near the 5 train in Sutton Place, with 17+ buildings currently matching this filter pair on Openigloo. Use this page to compare buildings that are market-relative affordable (median asking rent below the neighborhood median), without assuming they’re income-restricted or subsidized. Openigloo helps you vet buildings faster with rated-building signals, building-level details, and renter-focused Q&A so you can confirm what matters before you tour. Use the filters to narrow to the 5 train area and market-relative affordable options, then check the building directly for fees, deposits, and lease terms.

Affordable buildings near the 5 train in Sutton Place

Showing 1–17 of 17 affordable buildings near the 5 train in Sutton Place.

235 East 54 Street

235 East 54 Street

Sutton Place

No evictions
No open violations
1 litigation case
No bedbug history
210 East 58 Street
Rent-stabilized
Good cause

210 East 58 Street

Sutton Place

1 eviction
1 open violation
3 litigation cases
No bedbug history
136 East 55 Street
Rent-stabilized
Good cause

136 East 55 Street

4.1(11)

Sutton Place

No evictions
3 open violations
No litigation history
No bedbug history
400 East 54 Street
Rent-stabilized

400 East 54 Street

4.2(8)

Sutton Place

2 evictions
3 open violations
1 litigation case
No bedbug history
417 East 57 Street
Rent-stabilized

417 East 57 Street

4.6(8)

Sutton Place

2 evictions
2 open violations
No litigation history
No bedbug history
400 East 57 Street
Rent-stabilized
Good cause

400 East 57 Street

3.8(8)

Sutton Place

4 evictions
5 open violations
7 litigation cases
No bedbug history
405 East 54 Street
Rent-stabilized
Good cause

405 East 54 Street

3.5(6)

Sutton Place

7 evictions
22 open violations
5 litigation cases
No bedbug history
141 East 55 Street
Rent-stabilized

141 East 55 Street

3.4(5)

Sutton Place

No evictions
26 open violations
3 litigation cases
No bedbug history
232 East   54 Street
Rent-stabilized
Good cause

232 East 54 Street

4.9(4)

Sutton Place

1 eviction
1 open violation
No litigation history
No bedbug history
360 East 55 Street
Rent-stabilized
Good cause

360 East 55 Street

4.5(3)

Sutton Place

4 evictions
2 open violations
No litigation history
No bedbug history
250 East   54 Street
Good cause

250 East 54 Street

4.0(2)

Sutton Place

1 eviction
3 open violations
1 litigation case
No bedbug history
155 East 55 Street
Rent-stabilized

155 East 55 Street

2.6(2)

Sutton Place

No evictions
1 open violation
1 litigation case
No bedbug history
325 East 54 Street
Rent-stabilized
Good cause

325 East 54 Street

4.6(2)

Sutton Place

1 eviction
2 open violations
2 litigation cases
No bedbug history
327 East 54 Street
Rent-stabilized
Good cause

327 East 54 Street

3.6(2)

Sutton Place

1 eviction
No open violations
No litigation history
No bedbug history
245 East 54 Street
Rent-stabilized

245 East 54 Street

5.0(1)

Sutton Place

No evictions
No open violations
1 litigation case
No bedbug history
220 East 54 Street
Rent-stabilized

220 East 54 Street

4.7(1)

Sutton Place

1 eviction
3 open violations
No litigation history
No bedbug history
141 East 56 Street
Rent-stabilized
Good cause

141 East 56 Street

4.9(1)

Sutton Place

2 evictions
3 open violations
No litigation history
No bedbug history

What to check before for affordable buildings near the 5 train in Sutton Place

  • Expect 17+ eligible buildings after applying the 5-train + market-relative affordable filters; compare amenities, commute fit, and building rules across each.
  • Confirm the full monthly cost (broker fee, deposit requirements, and utilities), not just the asking rent, before you apply or sign.
  • Because “affordable” here is market-relative, verify the exact current pricing and any rent-change clauses in the lease.
  • If a building has restrictions (e.g., pet policies, move-in windows, documentation), ask before touring so you don’t lose time later.
  • Check whether there’s at least one available apartment in the building and review lease start dates and renewal expectations.

Nearby neighborhoods in Manhattan

More filters for affordable buildings near the 5 train in Sutton Place

Other building filters

Affordable buildings near the 5 train in other NYC boroughs

FAQ