Openigloo home

Pre-war buildings in Tottenville

Tottenville, situated on the southern tip of Staten Island, features a mix of residential buildings and is known for its quiet, suburban feel. The neighborhood boasts 38+ buildings, providing a variety of options for those seeking a home in this scenic area. Residents of Tottenville benefit from a community-oriented atmosphere and access to nearby parks and schools. Currently, the average building rating for rated buildings in this neighborhood stands at 3.75, making it a solid choice for prospective renters. (building-level trends; individual units can differ)

Discover a variety of pre-war buildings in Tottenville, Staten Island, with over 38+ buildings currently available. These vintage structures offer unique architectural charm and a sense of history that newer buildings may lack. At Openigloo, you can rely on tenant reviews and open-data signals to help inform your decisions. We provide a space where prospective renters can access valuable information and ask questions directly from other tenants, ensuring you have the insight you need before renting.

Pre-war buildings in Tottenville

Showing 1–18 of 38 pre-war buildings in Tottenville.

150 Johnson Avenue

150 Johnson Avenue

Tottenville

2 evictions
No open violations
No litigation history
No bedbug history
408 Loretto Street

408 Loretto Street

Tottenville

No evictions
8 open violations
No litigation history
No bedbug history
5309 Arthur Kill Road

5309 Arthur Kill Road

Tottenville

No evictions
3 open violations
2 litigation cases
No bedbug history
217 Fisher Avenue

217 Fisher Avenue

Tottenville

No evictions
6 open violations
No litigation history
No bedbug history
173 Wood Avenue

173 Wood Avenue

Tottenville

No evictions
1 open violation
No litigation history
No bedbug history
83 Tyrrell Street

83 Tyrrell Street

Tottenville

1 eviction
No open violations
No litigation history
No bedbug history
5268 Arthur Kill Road

5268 Arthur Kill Road

Tottenville

No evictions
1 open violation
No litigation history
No bedbug history
60 Tyrrell Street

60 Tyrrell Street

Tottenville

1 eviction
2 open violations
No litigation history
No bedbug history
7684 Amboy Road

7684 Amboy Road

Tottenville

2 evictions
5 open violations
No litigation history
No bedbug history
5422 Arthur Kill Road

5422 Arthur Kill Road

Tottenville

No evictions
6 open violations
No litigation history
No bedbug history
360 Brighton Street

360 Brighton Street

Tottenville

No evictions
14 open violations
No litigation history
No bedbug history
574 Craig Avenue

574 Craig Avenue

Tottenville

No evictions
2 open violations
No litigation history
No bedbug history
366 Brehaut Avenue

366 Brehaut Avenue

Tottenville

1 eviction
No open violations
No litigation history
No bedbug history
7372 Amboy Road
Good cause

7372 Amboy Road

Tottenville

No evictions
1 open violation
No litigation history
No bedbug history
162 Bethel Avenue

162 Bethel Avenue

Tottenville

No evictions
6 open violations
1 litigation case
No bedbug history
7255 Amboy Road
Good cause

7255 Amboy Road

Tottenville

No evictions
6 open violations
No litigation history
No bedbug history
7601 Amboy Road

7601 Amboy Road

Tottenville

No evictions
No open violations
1 litigation case
No bedbug history
137 Barnard Avenue

137 Barnard Avenue

Tottenville

No evictions
1 open violation
No litigation history
No bedbug history

What to check before for pre-war buildings in Tottenville

  • Expect classic architectural details such as high ceilings and hardwood floors in pre-war buildings.
  • Confirm building conditions and maintenance records before signing a lease; some pre-war buildings may require more upkeep.
  • Check for any additional fees, such as maintenance or utilities, which may not be included in the rent.
  • Review tenant feedback specific to each building to gauge the overall living experience.
  • Verify any pet policies if applicable; not all pre-war buildings may accommodate pets.

Nearby neighborhoods in Staten Island

Pre-war buildings in other NYC boroughs

FAQ