Summarized from anonymous rental reviews on Openigloo.
Recent tenant reviews for buildings managed by Nathan Fishman depict mixed experiences. Positive notes include generally clean premises, well-kept common areas, and responsive onsite staff such as supers. Many residents appreciate the community atmosphere and proximity to amenities. However, persistent issues with heating, outdated plumbing, occasional pest problems, and inconsistent management responsiveness surface frequently. Tenants also report problems with maintenance of appliances and building security concerns after hours. While some praise the landlord’s timeliness in addressing issues, others criticize management's attentiveness and communication, especially regarding repairs and transparency. Overall, while the properties offer good value, tenants should anticipate occasional management shortcomings.
Reviews
Former tenant·17 minutes ago
Good value in Washington heights
Pros
Great super & upkeep
Cons
Issues with elevator and pest
Former tenant·Over 1 year ago
Nice building, awful property manager
Pros
Proximity to subway, stores, affordable rent
Cons
Washer/dryers constantly broken, issues with heat and hot water, old pipes not maintained, pest control not adequate