What do tenants say about Andrew Garay?

Andrew Garay has an average tenant rating of 3.7 out of 5 across 13 reviews.

Would renters recommend buildings managed by Andrew Garay?

54% of tenants who reviewed buildings managed by Andrew Garay would recommend living there.

Is Andrew Garay responsive to tenants?

70% of tenants who reviewed a building managed by Andrew Garay approve of how it is run.

Has Andrew Garay had any evictions?

Andrew Garay has 2 recorded evictions across their portfolio.

Has Andrew Garay had any litigation cases?

Andrew Garay has no housing court litigation cases across their portfolio.

Is Andrew Garay on the worst landlords list?

Andrew Garay has not appeared on the NYC worst landlords list.

How many buildings does Andrew Garay own or manage?

Andrew Garay owns or manages 4 buildings totalling 95 units.

Andrew Garay

Head Officer·4 buildings·95 units

3.7

13 reviews

Highlights

Evictions

Litigation cases

About Andrew Garay

Andrew Garay is a mixed-profile head officer. Across their buildings, tenants rate them 3.7/5 across 13 reviews, with 54% recommending their buildings and 70% approving of them as an owner or associate. Their portfolio records 2 evictions, 0 open violations, and 0 litigation cases. Data last updated August 14, 2026. Andrew Garay is a Head Officer associated with 4 buildings and 95 units across Kips Bay and Gramercy Park in Manhattan. The portfolio spans multiple neighborhoods across Manhattan. The buildings were built primarily in the 1960s, with some originating from the 1910s. The portfolio is mostly mid-rise. All of the associated buildings have rent-stabilized apartments. Individual building ratings, tenant reviews, and public records are on the associated building pages.

Renter recommendations

Renters recommend associated buildings

Renters approve of this owner or associate

Review summary

Summarized from anonymous rental reviews on Openigloo.

Tenant reviews for buildings managed by Andrew Garay reveal a pattern of responsive and attentive superintendents praised for prompt maintenance and cleanliness. Many residents appreciate the well-kept common areas and convenient locations. However, recurring issues include thin, noisy walls, occasional pest infestations, and inconsistent management communication, particularly involving building managers like Sophia, who some renters find difficult and unhelpful. While amenities like elevators and laundry facilities are valued, some buildings show aging infrastructure concerns. Overall, tenants recognize the management's efforts but suggest improvements in noise insulation, pest control, and tenant relations to elevate the living experience.

Reviews

Former tenant·12 hours ago

Great apartment / no notes

Pros

Great location, quiet building, attentive super. Recently updated elevator and laundry

Cons

Thin walls so hear a lot of your neighbors from all directions

Former tenant·4 days ago

Good Very attentive building

Pros

The super is amazing and will help you with anything right away. The building is well maintained. No bug problems and great water pressure. Elevator is good.