Summarized from anonymous rental reviews on Openigloo.
Recent reviews for buildings managed by 5 WEST 95TH STREET reveal a mixed experience for tenants. While the buildings are praised for their convenient locations, quiet neighborhoods, and some friendly neighbors, significant issues persist. Pest problems with roaches and mice are frequent and difficult to resolve, greatly impacting tenant satisfaction. Cleanliness and garbage management vary but often fall short, contributing to negative impressions. Management responsiveness is inconsistent, with many tenants citing slow or unresponsive communication and outdated practices like requiring rent by mail check. Though some tenants appreciate amenities like laundry and elevators, maintenance issues such as leaks and slow elevator service remain.
Reviews
Former tenant·9 minutes ago
So many roaches
Pros
It was well located
Cons
Roaches, mice, can’t email the office, completely unresponsive
Advice to the owners
This building feels not fixable - it’s uninhabitable.
Former tenant·1 month ago
Great for couple
Pros
Pet friendly, close to Central Park, close to dining, laundry in building