Openigloo home

Top rated and most searched landlords in All Upper West Side

This page covers 29 owners and managers — who they are, what renters say about them, and what the city has on file. Use the page to identify owners and managers that renters look up often or rate highly, then investigate the specific buildings you are considering. The top-rated filter includes landlords rated 4.3 or higher with at least 10 reviews; the most-searched filter reflects how often renters look up their Openigloo profiles.

Compare review details and building-level information rather than relying on a rating alone. Check whether reviews describe the same property or management practices that matter to you, and look at available city records for additional context. Search activity shows renter interest, not a recommendation, and reviews or public records cannot establish what your experience will be.

Showing 19–29 of 29 top rated and most searched landlords in All Upper West Side.

Drew Spitler

4.4(17)
·
Top rated
Head Officer1 buildings616 units
11 evictions
1 litigation case

Stephen Benjamin

4.4(17)
·
Top rated
Officer1 buildings616 units
12 evictions
1 litigation case

Mark Hoffman

4.3(13)
·
Top rated
Head Officer24 buildings1,133 units
1 eviction
4 litigation cases

Fred Rosenberg

4.5(12)
·
Top rated
Site Manager13 buildings317 units
2 evictions
8 litigation cases

Sherwood Residential Management

4.5(12)
·
Top rated
Corporate Owner3 buildings292 units
2 evictions
6 litigation cases

Florence Goldsmith

4.5(11)
·
Top rated
Shareholder6 buildings103 units
No evictions
6 litigation cases

Amsterco 67 LLC

4.4(11)
·
Top rated
Corporate Owner1 buildings450 units
1 eviction
No litigation history

Marc Liard

4.4(11)
·
Top rated
Site Manager1 buildings450 units
1 eviction
No litigation history

Mariel Ventura

4.7(10)
·
Top rated
Site Manager1 buildings301 units
2 evictions
1 litigation case

West 60th Street Associates LLC

4.7(10)
·
Top rated
Corporate Owner1 buildings301 units
2 evictions
1 litigation case

Robert Rudaj

4.7(10)
·
Top rated
Agent1 buildings301 units
2 evictions
1 litigation case

What to check before renting from top rated and most searched landlords in All Upper West Side

  • Check whether renter reviews refer to the specific All Upper West Side building you are considering.
  • Compare recurring comments about repairs, communication, and lease-related issues across reviews.
  • Review available city records for information about the properties managed by an owner or company.
  • Treat profile search activity as a measure of renter interest, not as evidence of management quality.
  • Look for differences between a company-wide rating and comments about individual buildings.

Top rated and most searched landlords near All Upper West Side

Top rated and most searched landlords by borough

Landlords and management companies operate across different parts of the city. Browse by borough to see who runs the buildings where you are looking, along with their reviews and open-data records.

FAQ