Openigloo home

Top rated and most searched landlords in Upper West Side

31 top rated and most searched landlords in Upper West Side are cross-checked against the city's public records, with renter reviews where they exist. This page can help you narrow your research when considering a rental on the Upper West Side. “Most searched” refers to landlords whose profiles renters look up most often, while “top rated” means a renter rating of 4.3 or higher with at least 10 reviews. The two filters reflect different kinds of renter interest and feedback.

Use the profiles to compare renter comments and ratings with available city records for the owner, manager, and building. Reviews can describe individual experiences, while public records provide a separate source of information; neither alone establishes what your experience will be. Check the specific building and lease details, and look for patterns that are relevant to your needs.

Showing 1–18 of 31 top rated and most searched landlords in Upper West Side.

Halstead Management Co.

4.3(177)
·
Top rated
Corporate Owner220 buildings16,981 units
47 evictions
134 litigation cases

Solstice Residential Group, LLC

4.4(54)
·
Top rated
Corporate Owner71 buildings5,229 units
22 evictions
15 litigation cases

Thomas Toomey

4.4(89)
·
Top rated
Head Officer8 buildings2,152 units
33 evictions
3 litigation cases

Michael Lacy

4.4(89)
·
Top rated
Officer8 buildings2,152 units
33 evictions
3 litigation cases

Western Residential, Inc.

4.5(26)
·
Top rated
Corporate Owner5 buildings710 units
17 evictions
1 litigation case

Sequoia Property Mgmt Corp

4.5(17)
·
Top rated
Corporate Owner34 buildings1,455 units
1 eviction
4 litigation cases

Christopher Alker

4.3(59)
·
Top rated
Officer81 buildings5,779 units
22 evictions
22 litigation cases

Brown Harris Stevens

4.3(23)
·
Top rated
Corporate Owner117 buildings7,450 units
7 evictions
22 litigation cases

Alex Kalajian

4.3(21)
·
Top rated
Head Officer32 buildings2,202 units
6 evictions
5 litigation cases

Mark Hoffman

4.3(13)
·
Top rated
Head Officer24 buildings1,133 units
1 eviction
4 litigation cases

Wallack Management Company, Inc

4.4(24)
·
Top rated
Corporate Owner66 buildings4,126 units
7 evictions
20 litigation cases

Gumley Haft

4.4(14)
·
Top rated
Corporate Owner48 buildings3,165 units
2 evictions
15 litigation cases

Florence Goldsmith

4.5(11)
·
Top rated
Shareholder6 buildings103 units
No evictions
6 litigation cases

Trustees of Columbia University

4.3(235)
·
Top rated
Corporate Owner157 buildings4,725 units
26 evictions
29 litigation cases

David Greenberg

4.4(205)
·
Top rated
Head Officer138 buildings5,154 units
28 evictions
29 litigation cases

Monica Kuth

4.4(205)
·
Top rated
Officer138 buildings5,154 units
28 evictions
29 litigation cases

Tri Properties LLC

4.4(18)
·
Top rated
Corporate Owner5 buildings85 units
No evictions
1 litigation case

George Davis

4.4(18)
·
Top rated
Site Manager1 buildings100 units
2 evictions
No litigation history

What to check before renting from top rated and most searched landlords in Upper West Side

  • Check whether the profile identifies the owner, the management company, or both.
  • Read renter reviews for details about repairs, communication, and lease issues.
  • Compare the listed building information with the address and records for the rental you are considering.
  • Treat profile searches as a measure of renter interest, not as evidence of a landlord’s quality.
  • Review public records alongside renter feedback before drawing conclusions.

Top rated and most searched landlords near Upper West Side

Top rated and most searched landlords by borough

Landlords and management companies operate across different parts of the city. Browse by borough to see who runs the buildings where you are looking, along with their reviews and open-data records.

FAQ