Openigloo home

Most reviewed and most searched landlords in Elmhurst

You can compare 51 most reviewed and most searched landlords in Elmhurst on reviews, portfolio size and open-data history. The labels reflect two different renter signals: these landlords have the most renter reviews on Openigloo or their profiles are looked up most often. A place on this page does not, by itself, show whether a landlord is responsive or whether a building will suit your needs. Use the signals to identify records worth examining, then check the details for the specific property you are considering.

Compare review comments and dates with portfolio information and open-data history. Look for recurring issues, note whether reviews describe the same building or different properties, and verify relevant records independently. Reviews and profile searches are not a complete account of a landlord’s practices, and open-data records may not capture every aspect of your rental experience.

Showing 37–51 of 51 most reviewed and most searched landlords in Elmhurst.

Anthony Pistilli

3.0(35)
Shareholder38 buildings1,642 units
70 evictions
232 litigation cases

Pistilli Management LLC

2.9(30)
Corporate Owner30 buildings1,423 units
67 evictions
230 litigation cases

Arthur Wiener

3.4(26)
Shareholder38 buildings2,464 units
50 evictions
94 litigation cases

Theo Management Corp

3.6(23)
Corporate Owner13 buildings546 units
22 evictions
14 litigation cases

Barry Fishman

3.8(22)
Shareholder17 buildings723 units
16 evictions
8 litigation cases

Ina Feinstein

3.8(22)
Shareholder16 buildings676 units
16 evictions
7 litigation cases

Billy Haugh

3.5(22)
Shareholder12 buildings744 units
4 evictions
19 litigation cases

Eli Tabak

2.6(21)
Head Officer5 buildings289 units
19 evictions
15 litigation cases

Menachem Augenstein

2.6(21)
Site Manager5 buildings289 units
19 evictions
15 litigation cases

Themistokles Theodosopoulos

3.6(17)
Head Officer9 buildings373 units
15 evictions
13 litigation cases

Ania Property Management Inc

3.2(16)
Corporate Owner8 buildings402 units
21 evictions
27 litigation cases

Big City Property Management, Inc.

3.2(14)
Corporate Owner9 buildings205 units
5 evictions
7 litigation cases

Leonard Zangas

3.9(13)
Site Manager104 buildings2,442 units
47 evictions
42 litigation cases

Zion Mgmt

3.0(12)
Corporate Owner22 buildings792 units
54 evictions
160 litigation cases

Blue Owl Management LLC

4.1(9)
Corporate Owner71 buildings872 units
4 evictions
32 litigation cases

What to check before renting from most reviewed and most searched landlords in Elmhurst

  • Check whether reviews discuss the Elmhurst property you are considering or another building in the landlord’s portfolio.
  • Read review details for recurring maintenance, communication or lease-related concerns rather than relying on visibility alone.
  • Compare a landlord’s portfolio information with the address and ownership details for the property you plan to rent.
  • Review available open-data history for records relevant to the building, and confirm details through the underlying public sources.

Most reviewed and most searched landlords near Elmhurst

Most reviewed and most searched landlords by borough

Landlords and management companies operate across different parts of the city. Browse by borough to see who runs the buildings where you are looking, along with their reviews and open-data records.

FAQ