Openigloo home

Most reviewed and most searched landlords in Manhattan

Openigloo tracks 18 most reviewed and most searched landlords in Manhattan, drawn from city records and reviews left by renters. This page can help you compare landlords in Manhattan when renter reviews and profile lookup activity are part of your due diligence. The two filters reflect different signals: one identifies landlords with the most renter reviews on Openigloo, while the other identifies profiles renters look up most often.

Use both signals as starting points, then read the reviews for specifics and check the relevant building’s records. Review volume and profile interest do not establish how a landlord will handle your tenancy, and they may not describe every building a company manages. Compare details for the property you are considering, including its address and reported conditions, before drawing conclusions.

Showing 1–18 of 18 most reviewed and most searched landlords in Manhattan.

Livingston Management Services LLC

3.2(515)
Corporate Owner253 buildings4,220 units
283 evictions
580 litigation cases

Nieuw Amsterdam Property Management

2.8(344)
Corporate Owner248 buildings5,788 units
758 evictions
1,101 litigation cases

Bpp St Owner LLC

4.2(339)
Corporate Owner38 buildings3,579 units
85 evictions
21 litigation cases

Gpg Management

3.6(285)
Corporate Owner160 buildings3,324 units
77 evictions
63 litigation cases

Mark Scharfman

3.4(281)
·
Worst landlord
Head Officer130 buildings3,482 units
181 evictions
372 litigation cases

Urban Associates LLC

3.9(267)
Corporate Owner53 buildings6,238 units
136 evictions
35 litigation cases

Centennial Properties NY

3.0(252)
Corporate Owner108 buildings1,541 units
57 evictions
244 litigation cases

Smajlje Srdanovic

3.5(233)
Site Manager82 buildings7,836 units
470 evictions
387 litigation cases

Halstead Management Co.

4.3(177)
·
Top rated
Corporate Owner220 buildings16,981 units
47 evictions
134 litigation cases

Bldg Management Co., Inc.

3.9(175)
Corporate Owner79 buildings3,822 units
115 evictions
81 litigation cases

Rcr Management Group LLC

3.3(152)
Corporate Owner71 buildings3,049 units
86 evictions
177 litigation cases

Mgt Property Management LLC

3.4(150)
Corporate Owner46 buildings1,483 units
39 evictions
125 litigation cases

New Park Management, LLC

3.1(148)
Corporate Owner63 buildings4,152 units
157 evictions
264 litigation cases

John Ilibassi

3.6(139)
Shareholder87 buildings2,345 units
45 evictions
53 litigation cases

Salon Realty Corp

3.5(130)
Corporate Owner81 buildings1,719 units
23 evictions
69 litigation cases

Arya Management LLC

3.3(124)
Corporate Owner87 buildings783 units
28 evictions
100 litigation cases

Tristar Management Associates LLC

3.4(114)
Corporate Owner75 buildings918 units
44 evictions
234 litigation cases

Matel Realty LLC

3.5(113)
Corporate Owner42 buildings818 units
5 evictions
10 litigation cases

What to check before renting from most reviewed and most searched landlords in Manhattan

  • Read individual reviews for details about maintenance, communication, and recurring concerns.
  • Check whether a review refers to the specific Manhattan building you are considering.
  • Treat profile lookup activity as a measure of renter interest, not as a rating of management quality.
  • Compare landlord names and building addresses with city records to confirm you are researching the right property.

Most reviewed and most searched landlords in trending Manhattan neighborhoods

Most reviewed and most searched landlords by borough

Landlords and management companies operate across different parts of the city. Browse by borough to see who runs the buildings where you are looking, along with their reviews and open-data records.

FAQ