Openigloo home

Most reviewed agents in NYC

Openigloo lists 100 most reviewed agents in NYC, each with the buildings they run and what the city's records show. These listings are valuable for renters seeking agents with substantial feedback from past clients, as they provide insights into the agent's reliability and performance. When using this information, compare agents based on their ratings and the context of the reviews, noting that while a high number of reviews can indicate experience, it does not guarantee future service quality.

Showing 37–54 of 100 most reviewed agents in NYC.

Naftali Hager

3.1(112)
Head Officer48 buildings1,535 units
111 evictions
150 litigation cases

Adam Grushko

4.1(112)
Officer18 buildings2,368 units
42 evictions
19 litigation cases

Estates NY Real Estate Services LLC

3.6(110)
Corporate Owner37 buildings3,531 units
269 evictions
231 litigation cases

Martin Scharf

3.7(107)
·
Worst landlord
Shareholder44 buildings2,504 units
107 evictions
172 litigation cases

Carlyle Construction Corp

4.2(107)
Corporate Owner7 buildings1,983 units
17 evictions
13 litigation cases

Michael Dimson

4.2(107)
Head Officer7 buildings1,983 units
17 evictions
13 litigation cases

Tf Cornerstone INC

4.5(104)
·
Top rated
Agent3 buildings650 units
1 eviction
No litigation history

Steven Phillips

4.5(104)
·
Top rated
Agent1 buildings650 units
1 eviction
No litigation history

Charles Schwartz

3.7(101)
Site Manager50 buildings410 units
8 evictions
17 litigation cases

Rose Associates, INC.

4.2(100)
Corporate Owner30 buildings3,806 units
49 evictions
15 litigation cases

Gerard Darcy

4.3(100)
·
Top rated
Agent1 buildings576 units
6 evictions
No litigation history

Hager Management INC

3.1(98)
Corporate Owner42 buildings1,407 units
96 evictions
119 litigation cases

Greenetree Management

3.6(96)
Corporate Owner22 buildings519 units
25 evictions
12 litigation cases

Gotham Real Estate Managers LLC

4.3(95)
·
Top rated
Corporate Owner9 buildings2,010 units
41 evictions
13 litigation cases

Buchbinder & Warren LLC

4.1(93)
Corporate Owner126 buildings2,374 units
14 evictions
12 litigation cases

Michael Lacy

3.7(90)
Head Officer1 buildings739 units
18 evictions
No litigation history

Michael Aryeh

3.4(89)
Shareholder31 buildings958 units
60 evictions
186 litigation cases

Thomas Rohlman

3.6(88)
Head Officer31 buildings699 units
25 evictions
64 litigation cases

What to check before renting from most reviewed agents in NYC

  • Check agents' ratings alongside the reviews for a comprehensive understanding of their service.
  • Look for patterns in reviews to gauge consistency in performance and client satisfaction.
  • Consider the specific buildings an agent manages to assess their experience in your preferred areas.
  • Investigate how recently the reviews were written to ensure relevance to current service levels.

Most reviewed agents in trending NYC neighborhoods

Most reviewed agents by borough

Landlords and management companies operate across different parts of the city. Browse by borough to see who runs the buildings where you are looking, along with their reviews and open-data records.

FAQ