Openigloo home

Most reviewed property management companies in NYC

You can compare 100 most reviewed property management companies in NYC on reviews, portfolio size and open-data history. Use the reviews to identify recurring themes in how tenants describe a company’s management, including maintenance, communication and lease issues. “Most reviewed” refers to companies with the most renter reviews on Openigloo; it does not mean the reviews are uniformly positive or that every building is represented.

Compare each company’s feedback with its portfolio and available public-record history. Look for patterns across reviews, note when experiences differ, and check whether the records relate to the building you are considering. Reviews and public data can inform your questions, but they do not establish what your experience will be or prove that a concern applies to every property the company manages.

Showing 1–18 of 100 most reviewed property management companies in NYC.

Livingston Management Services LLC

3.2(515)
Corporate Owner253 buildings4,220 units
283 evictions
580 litigation cases

Rose Property Mgmt Grp LLC

3.8(421)
Corporate Owner132 buildings10,060 units
135 evictions
110 litigation cases

Equity Residential Management, LLC

4.2(354)
Corporate Owner24 buildings5,289 units
81 evictions
23 litigation cases

Nieuw Amsterdam Property Management

2.8(344)
Corporate Owner248 buildings5,788 units
758 evictions
1,101 litigation cases

Tri-Hill Management LLC

3.4(289)
Corporate Owner159 buildings3,712 units
161 evictions
426 litigation cases

Gpg Management

3.6(285)
Corporate Owner160 buildings3,324 units
77 evictions
63 litigation cases

C&C Apartment Management

3.0(274)
Corporate Owner483 buildings15,206 units
1,173 evictions
1,082 litigation cases

Stellar Management

3.5(246)
Corporate Owner88 buildings7,997 units
504 evictions
401 litigation cases

Dalan Management

3.5(235)
Corporate Owner49 buildings1,472 units
36 evictions
63 litigation cases

Douglas Elliman Property Management

4.2(234)
Corporate Owner508 buildings40,660 units
720 evictions
360 litigation cases

Columbus Property Management

3.5(194)
Corporate Owner10 buildings2,953 units
259 evictions
65 litigation cases

Choice NY Management

3.3(183)
Corporate Owner199 buildings4,401 units
80 evictions
265 litigation cases

Stonehenge Management LLC

4.0(178)
Corporate Owner30 buildings3,856 units
65 evictions
36 litigation cases

Halstead Management Co.

4.3(177)
·
Top rated
Corporate Owner220 buildings16,981 units
47 evictions
134 litigation cases

Related Management

4.2(175)
Corporate Owner110 buildings10,134 units
143 evictions
94 litigation cases

Bldg Management Co., Inc.

3.9(175)
Corporate Owner79 buildings3,822 units
115 evictions
81 litigation cases

Yht Management

2.9(161)
Corporate Owner104 buildings545 units
69 evictions
270 litigation cases

Rcr Management Group LLC

3.3(152)
Corporate Owner71 buildings3,049 units
86 evictions
177 litigation cases

What to check before renting from most reviewed property management companies in NYC

  • Check whether reviews describe specific buildings or management practices across a company’s portfolio.
  • Compare recurring maintenance comments with the company’s available public-record history.
  • Note the dates and details in reviews to understand whether feedback reflects a current or past experience.
  • Ask who handles repairs and tenant communication at the specific building you are considering.

Most reviewed property management companies in trending NYC neighborhoods

Most reviewed property management companies by borough

Landlords and management companies operate across different parts of the city. Browse by borough to see who runs the buildings where you are looking, along with their reviews and open-data records.

FAQ